COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, SALES TAX (WEST), KARACHI vs Messrs K & A INDUSTRIES, KARACHI
This petition, filed by the Collector of Customs, Sales Tax (West), Karachi, challenges an order of the High Court of Sindh Karachi which allowed an appeal by the respondent and struck down a demand for Additional Tax on the ground that the show-cause notice was time-barred. The core legal question before the Supreme Court of Pakistan was whether the show-cause notice dated 12th August 1999, issued in respect of the tax year 1994-95, was within the prescribed limitation period of three years under subsection (2) of section 36 of the Sales Tax Act. The Supreme Court held that the petitioner's counsel failed to explain how the notice was within the prescribed limitation and concluded that the show-cause notice was indeed served beyond the period of limitation prescribed by the statute. Consequently, the petition was dismissed and leave to appeal was declined, affirming the High Court's decision to non-suit the petitioner based on limitation.
- Whether a show-cause notice issued under the Sales Tax Act beyond the prescribed limitation period of three years is legally sustainable?
- Does a demand for Additional Tax survive if the underlying show-cause notice is time-barred under subsection (2) of section 36 of the Sales Tax Act?
- subsection (2) of section 36 of the Sales Tax Act
ORDER
IFTIKHAR MUHAMMAD CHAUDHRY, C.J.---This petition calls in question the following order passed by the High Court of Sindh Karachi:-- "By the impugned order the appeal filed by the respondent was allowed and the demand of Additional Tax was struck down for the reason that the show-cause notice, dated 12-8-1999 was beyond the prescribed limitation, in terms of subsection (2) of section 36 of the Sales Tax Act, Mr. Abdul Sattar Silat was not able to dislodge the finding which is based on facts. Consequently, the appeal has no merits and the same is dismissed, with no order as to costs."
2. Learned counsel when confronted with the provisions of subsection (2) of section 36 of the Sales Tax Act, and was called upon to explain as to whether in respect of the year of 1994-95, show- cause notice, dated 12th August, 1999, was within the prescribed limitation i,e, three years. He could not answer satisfactorily. Thus it is held that show-cause notice was served beyond the period of limitation as prescribed in subsection (2) of section 36 of the Sales Tax Act and as such learned High Court had rightly non-suited the petitioner.
' Petition is dismissed and leave declined. revisions by the competent authorities. Therefore, it is advisable to consult the official sources or legal professionals for the most up-to-date and accurate information.
Cited by 24 cases
- FOUNDATION WIND ENERGY-II Versus COMMISSIONER PUNJAB REVENUE AUTHORITY 2026 PTD 542
- M/s Popular Sugar Mills Ltd vs Fed. of Pakistan and Others 2024 SHC 870
- POPULAR SUGAR MILLS LTD. Versus FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN 2026 PTD 123
- M/s Zhongxing Telecom Pakistan (Pvt) Ltd vs Commissioner Inland 2022 ATIR 10
- Qasim International Container Terminal vs Collector, Model Customs 2020 SHC 960
- M/s Hascol Petroleum Ltd vs Fed. of Pakistan and Ors 2020 SHC 802
- Messrs Waqas Enterprises, Faisalabad vs The Commissioner Inland 2021 PTD (Trib.) 1508
- Salman Enterprises, Karachi vs The Deputy Director, Directorate General Of PCA, Custom House, Karachi and 2 others 2022 PTD (Trib.) 144
- Commissioner Inland Revenue vs (M/S) Irfan Industries (Pvt.) Ltd. 2020 PTD 810, 2019 PCTLR 683
- The COMMISSIONER INLAND REVENUE, ZONE-I, R.T.O., HYDERABAD vs Messrs 2019 P.C.T.L.R. 26, 2018 PTD (Trib.) 2235
- AIRBLUE LIMITED Versus COMMISSIONER INLAND REVENUE, ZONE-I, ISLAMABAD 2018 PTD 2287
- Messrs MAYFAIR IMPEX, KARACHI vs COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, CENTRAL 2018 PTD (Trib.) 1131
- Messrs GARDEN TOWN, PHASE-II, GUJRANWALA vs COMMISSIONER INLAND 2016 PTD (Trib.) 2362
- Messrs PHILIP MORRIS (PAKISTAN) LTD., KARACHI vs The ADDITIONAL 2016 PTD (Trib.) 1008
- M/s J.K. Brothers Pakistan (Pvt.) Ltd. vs The Additional Commissioner Inland 2015 LHC 6025
- Messrs J.K. BROTHERS PAKISTAN (PVT.) LTD. through Director vs The ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER INLAND REVENUE and another 2016 PLJ Lahore 35, PTCL 2016 CL. 507, 2016 PTD 461
- Messrs LUCKY PARAGON READY MIX LTD., KARACHI vs C.I.R., (APPEALS-IV), KARACHI 2017 PTD (Trib.) 156
- DEWAN SALMAN FIBER LTD. Versus The COLLECTOR (APPEALS) 2014 PTD 52
- Messrs AL-QUTAB ENTERPRISES vs ADDITIONAL COLLECTOR CUSTOMS and another 2013 PTD (Trib.) 1913
- Messrs OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT COMPANY LIMITED, ISLAMABAD vs COMMISSIONER INLAND REVENUE, (ZONE-I), ISLAMABAD and 2 others 2013 PTD (Trib.) 1246
- COMMISSIONER (LEGAL DIVISION) INLAND REVENUE (RTO), FAISALABAD vs Messrs ZAHID JEE FABRICS (PVT.) LTD., FAISALABAD 2012 P.C.T.L.R. 1143, 2012 PTD (Trib.) 1040
- Commissioner (Legal Division) Inland Revenue (RTO),Faisalabad vs M/S. 2012 P.C.T.L.R. 1143
- 2010 PTD 1759 2010 PTD 1759
- M/s.J.K. BROTHERS PAKISTAN PVT. LTD. vs ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER INLAND 2016 PLJ Lahore 35