Messrs ZARGHOON ZARAI CORPORATION vs COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS and another
This petition arises from an order of the Sindh High Court dismissing the petitioner's Special Customs Appeal against the Customs, Central Excise and Sales Tax Tribunal's order, which had upheld the Order-in-Original passed by the Additional Collector Customs regarding the seizure of goods. The core legal question was whether the determination of the origin of seized goods constituted a question of law or fact under Section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969, and whether the High Court could interfere with concurrent findings of fact. The Supreme Court held that the concurrent findings of fact recorded by the Tribunal and the Additional Collector regarding whether the goods were of foreign or local origin did not raise any question of law for determination by the High Court under Section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969. The key principle laid down is that the High Court rightly declines to exercise its appellate jurisdiction under the Customs Act when the matter involves pure questions of fact concluded by the departmental forums without any legal infirmity or error of law.
- Whether the determination of the origin of seized goods is a question of fact or law under Section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969?
- Can the High Court interfere with concurrent findings of fact recorded by the Tribunal and the customs authorities?
- Does an appeal lie to the High Court under Section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969 on purely factual controversies?
- Section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969
ORDER
' RANA BHAGWANDAS, J.---Petitioner is aggrieved by Sindh High Court order, dated 15-3-2005 dismissing Special Customs Appeal of the petitioner against the order passed by Customs, Central Excise and Sales Tax Tribunal upholding Order-in-Original passed by Additional Collector Customs.
2. Operative part of the impugned order reads as under:- "We have heard the learned counsel at length with reference to the relevant facts and the questions proposed in this appeal. The moot point for consideration in the matter is that whether the goods seized from the appellant were not of foreign origin and the appellant was in lawful custody of the same. By majority view, the Tribunal has recorded its findings against the appellant on this point which is a finding of fact deciding the fate of appellant's claim.
' In view of above, in our opinion, none of the questions proposed in this appeal is a question of law within the ambit of section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969. This appeal has, therefore, no merits and the same is accordingly dismissed along with listed application."
3. After hearing learned counsel for the petitioner, we are firmly of the view that the vital question of fact as to whether the goods were of Iranian origin or local made has been concluded by the Tribunal as well as the Additional Collector of Customs, which does not raise any question of law for determination by the High Court in terms of section 196 of the Customs Act, 1969. High Court was, therefore, perfectly justified to decline exercise of its jurisdiction as under the relevant law only a question of law can be raised before it in such appeal. In our considered opinion, the impugned judgment does not suffer from any legal infirmity, material irregularity or error of law or of jurisdiction.
4. Consequently, the petition fails and is hereby dismissed as being without any merit and substance.
Cited by 14 cases
- KHYBER TEA AND FOOD COMPANY Versus COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE (APPEALS), PESHAWAR 2025 PTD 1914
- Collector of Customs, Model Customs Collectorate, Jamrud Road, Peshawar vs Messrs Khyber Tea And Food Company and 2 others 2022 PTD 1477
- Collector of Customs, Model Customs Collectorate, Peshawar vs Messrs 2022 PTD 1616
- Director Intelligence and Investigation, (Customs), Peshawar vs Messrs 2022 PTD 1496
- Al-Khair Traders vs Collector Customs 2015 PTD 2114, 2015 P.C.T.L.R. 1283
- Messrs AL-KHAIR TRADERS through Sole Proprietor vs COLLECTOR CUSTOMS 2015 PTD 2114
- ARSLAN POULTRY (PVT.) LTD. vs OFFICER INLAND REVENUE and others 2015 PTD 448
- Messrs WIN PIPE INDUSTRIES (PVT.) LTD. vs ADDITIONAL COLLECTOR and others 2014 P.C.T.L.R. 692, 2014 PTD 1915
- M/s. Win Pipe Industries (Pvt.) Ltd vs Additional Collector and others NLR 2015 Tax 134, PTCL 2015 CL.646
- Messrs KHYBER TEA AND FOOD COMPANY, PESHAWAR and others vs COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS (APPEALS), PESHAWAR and 6 others 2013 PTD (Trib.) 327
- Collector Of Customs, Model Customs Collectorate Of Paccs, Karachi vs Messrs Kapron Overseas Supplies Co. (Pvt.) Ltd.,Karachi 2010 P.C.T.L.R. 981
- COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, MODEL CUSTOMS COLLECTORATE OF PaCCS, KARACHI(PVT.) LTD., KARACHI vs Messrs KAPRON OVERSEAS SUPPLIES CO 2010 PTD 465
- Collector Of Customs, Model Customs Collectorate Of PACCS vs M/S. 2011 P.C.T.LR. 1121
- COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, MODEL CUSTOMS COLLECTORATE OF APPRAISEMENT, KARACHI vs Messrs SUPERIOR STEEL, KARACHI 2009 PTD 1239