SHEHZORE and anothers vs THE STATE
The applicant sought post-arrest bail in Crime No. 8 of 2005 registered at Police Station Karan Sharif, District Shikarpur, under Section 395 of the Pakistan Penal Code 1860, for allegedly committing dacoity by removing wheat crops using a tractor trolley. The core legal question was whether the applicant was entitled to bail considering the alternative punishment provided under Section 395, Pakistan Penal Code 1860, and the delay in lodging the F.I.R. along with prior civil litigation between the parties. The Sindh High Court held that the applicants were entitled to bail in view of the sentencing structure and precedents. The court laid down the principle that where an alternative lesser sentence is provided for an offense, and relying on established case law, bail may be granted, subject to furnishing surety, while directing the trial court to expedite proceedings.
- Whether an accused charged under Section 395 of the Pakistan Penal Code 1860 is entitled to post-arrest bail when an alternative lesser sentence is provided?
- Does the inclusion of an alternative sentence of imprisonment not less than four years affect the grant of bail in dacoity cases?
- Whether delay in lodging the F.I.R. and previous civil litigation between parties constitute grounds for granting bail?
- Section 395, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
ORDER
1. ' KHILIJI ARIF HUSSAIN, J.---The applicant seeks bail in Crime No,8 of 2005 registered at Police Station Karan Sharif District Shikarpur.
2. ' The allegation against the applicant is that on 1-5-2006 he along with co-accused Ali Bahar, Habibullah having gun, Suhno and Illahi Bux having pistol and Babo having Lathi brought thrasher on the land of complainant, thrashed his wheat crop lying in the land weighing 30 mounds and took away in the trolly of tractor by show of force within view of the complainant. The incident occurred on 1-5-2006 at 2030 hours of night whereas the F.I.R. Was lodged on 12-5-2006.
3. ' Mr. Muhammad Ayaz Soomro, learned counsel for the applicant argued that under section 395, P.P.C. Alternate punishment has been provided viz. Imprisonment for life or imprisonment not less than four years and more than 10 years and contended that when the alternate sentence has been provided then lesser sentence should be considered by the Court and in support of his contention he relied upon the case of Arshad Mehmood v. The State (1985 PCr.LJ 2048) and Muhammad Akhtar v. The State (1994 PCr.LJ 2340). He further contended that value of 30mounds wheat is about Rs,12,000 only and the allegation against the applicant has been levelled due to enmity between the parties and in this regard relied upon photocopy of the order passed in Suit No,151 of 2005 pending between the parties in the Court of Senior Civil Judge, Shikarpur.
4. ' On the other hand, learned State Counsel argued that name of the applicant appears in the F.I.R.
5. And specific role has been assigned to him.
6. ' I have taken into consideration the respective ' arguments advanced by the learned Advocates foi the parties and perused the record. Section 395, P.P.C. Provides that whoever commits Dacoity shall be punished with imprisonment for life, on rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall nor be less than four years nor more than ten years and shall also be liable to fine. The sentence not less than four years was incorporated by Ordinance III of 1980 on 3rd February, 1980 which make the intention of the legislature very clear that when the case is registered under section 395, P.P.C. The Court cannot award sentence less than four years and can award sentence not more than ten years.
7. Respectfully following the principle laid down in the case of Arshad Mehmood (supra) and Muhammad Akhtar (supra) the applicants are admitted to bail subject to his furnishing surety in the sum of Rs,50,000 and P.R. Bond in the like amount each to the satisfaction of trial Court.
8. However, the learned trial Court is directed to expedite the proceedings and dispose of the matter as early as possible.
Cited by 46 cases
- Nabeel son of Doshambay vs The State 2025 SHC KHI 1724
- Abdul Malik Munhano vs The State 2025 SHC SUK 1626
- Barkat ullah Versus State 2025 PCrLJ 994
- Barkat Ullah vs The State & another 2024 IHC 250, 2025 PCRLJ 994
- MUHAMMAD YASEEN S/O MATEEN vs THE STATE 2024 SHC 192
- Zulfiqar Ali vs The State 2023 SHC 842
- Mustafa Sikander vs The State 2023 SHC 892
- Abdul Hadi alias Babul and 2 others vs The State 2024 PCRLJ 1521
- Muhammad Eidan vs The State 2022 P Cr. L J 143
- ABDUL BARI KHAN Versus State 2021 PCrLJN 56
- ATTA MUHAMMAD Versus State 2020 PCrLJ 1221
- Rahim vs The State 2021 P Cr. L J 509
- ABDUL AZIZ Versus State 2022 PCrLJN 118
- MUHAMMAD SHAHZAD Versus State 2022 YLRN 111
- Haji MALOOK Versus State 2022 YLRN 209
- MUHAMMAD ALI KHAN alias CHOTO Versus State 2020 YLRN 45
- MUHAMMAD ISHAQUE vs The STATE 2019 YLR 677
- Kamran Khan & another vs The State & another 2017 LHC 3489
- KAMRAN KHAN and another vs STATE and another PLJ 2018 Cr.C. (Lahore) 413
- KAMRAN KHAN and another vs The STATE and another PLJ 2018 Cr.C. (Lahore) 413, 2018 MLD 479
- ZAHID MEHMOOD Versus State 2018 YLRN 143
- IMDAD HUSSAIN Versus State 2017 PCrLJN 13
- RASOOL BUX and 2 others vs STATE PLJ 2016 Cr.C. (Karachi) 767
- ZAMEER HUSSAIN Versus State 2017 YLRN 381
- ABDUL LATIF Versus State 2016 PCrLJN 122
- ABID alias AABI ARAIN Versus State 2016 PCrLJN 109
- YOUSIF Versus State 2016 PCrLJN 60
- Muhammad Nadeem vs The State, etc. 2015 P.C.T.L.R. 809
- SAJID HUSSAIN alias BARA and 2 others vs The STATE 2015 YLR 2111
- SHARIFUDDIN vs The STATE 2015 YLR 1791
- MUHAMMAD SHAKEEL vs The STATE 2015 MLD 886
- TALIB HUSSAIN vs The STATE 2014 YLR 1319
- AHMEDO vs The STATE 2013 MLD 1249
- IRFAN and 2 others vs The STATE 2013 MLD 1185
- ZAHID MASEEH and another vs THE STATE 2012 MLD 814
- NAZEER and 4 others vs THE STATE 2012 YLR 1302
- AMEER HAYAT and 2 others vs THE STATE 2012 YLR 1104
- ISMAIL vs THE STATE 2012 MLD 617
- GHULAM RASOOL and another vs THE STATE 2012 YLR 923
- MEVO RIND vs THE STATE 2012 YLR 151
- AMANULLAH Versus State 2012 YLR 103
- MUHAMMAD FAYAZ vs THE STATE 2010 YLR 1934
- BASHIR AHMED vs THE STATE---Complainant 2008 PLD Karachi 215
- GHULAM HUSSAIN and another vs THE STATE 2007 YLR 3210
- Ahmedo Kandrani vs State
- Hamood-ur-Rehman Khan Niazi & Ibad-ur-Rehman Khan Niazi vs The State