MAHMOOD YASIR and another vs THE STATE
This is a criminal miscellaneous matter where the petitioners sought the transfer of a challan case arising from F.I.R. No. 124 of 2006 under sections 420, 467, 468, and 471 of the Pakistan Penal Code 1860 from the Court of the Judicial Magistrate, Section 30, Talambah, Mianchannu to the Court of the Judicial Magistrate at Sahiwal, where another challan case arising from F.I.R. No. 139 of 2006 under sections 381-A and 411 of the Pakistan Penal Code 1860 involving the same vehicle and the same accused was already pending. The core legal question was whether two separate challan cases registered in different districts regarding the same vehicle and the same accused persons can be transferred and tried together before a single court. The Lahore High Court held that since both offences arose from the same series of acts or transactions and no prejudice would be caused to any party, the case could be transferred. The court laid down the principle that multiple criminal cases involving the same parties and connected transactions can be consolidated and tried by the same court in the interest of justice.
- Can two separate challan cases regarding the same vehicle and the same accused pending in different districts be transferred and tried together?
- Whether the transfer of a criminal challan case causes prejudice to the parties when offences are committed in the same series of acts or transactions?
- Section 381-A, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
- Section 411, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
- Section 420, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
- Section 467, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
- Section 468, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
- Section 471, Pakistan Penal Code 1860
ORDER
' MIAN HAMID FAROOQ, J.---Respondent No,3 lodged a report regarding theft of his Car bearing No,131/LXD; a case was registered vide F.I.R. No, 139 of 2006, dated 10-3-2006, under sections 381- A/411, P.P.C. With Police Station Farid Town, Sahiwal and now the challan is pending before Judicial Magistrate, Police Station Farid Town, Sahiwal. Subsequently, the police of Police Station Talambah, Tehsil Mianchannu arrested the petitioner and respondent No,4 and F.I.R. No,124 of 2006, dated 12- 5-2006 under sections 420/ 467/471, P.P.C. In respect of the aforesaid vehicle was registered. The challan of this case is pending before the Magistrate, Section 30, Police Station Talambah, Mianchannu. Now the petitioner seeks the transfer of the challan case of F.I.R. No,124 of 2006 titled The State v. Muhammad Yasir and others pending in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Section 30, Police Station Talambah, Mianchannu to the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Police Station Farid Town, Sahiwal, where challan case of F.I.R. No,139/2006 is pending regarding the same vehicle. The petitioners seek the following relief:- ' "In the light of above submissions, it is, therefore, very humbly prayed that this honourable Court may graciously be pleased to accept the instant petition and order to withdraw the challan case F.I.R. No,124/2006, under sections 420/467/468/471, P. P.C. Police Station Talambah, Tehsil Mianchannu, District Khanewal, pending in the Court of respondent No,2, titled as State v.
Muhammad Yasir and others and may kindly be ordered to be tried with main case F.I.R. No, 139/2006 under sections 384-A/411, P.P.C. Titled as State v. Muhammad Yasir and others pending in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Police Station Farid Town, Sahiwal in the interest of justice.
' It is further prayed that pending the disposal of this petition proceedings of both the challan cases may kindly be ordered to be stayed meanwhile."
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that since the case for theft of car was registered at Police Station Farid Town, Sahiwal, therefore, the case regarding the same vehicle, pending before Judicial Magistrate, Police Station Talambah, Mianchannu, may be transferred to Sahiwal and consolidated. The learned State Counsel has no objection for transfer of the case. None has entered appearance on behalf of other respondents to contest this petition.
3. I have heard the learned counsel and examined the available record. Admittedly two F.I.Rs, were lodged in two different Districts regarding theft of same vehicle and two challans are pending before different Courts. In both the cases, the accused persons are the same. Both the offences seem to be committed in same series of acts/transactions. To my mind, in case both the challans are entrusted to one Court, it would not cause prejudice to any of the parties. I see no legal impediment in transferring the challan case from Mianchannu to Sahiwal.
4. In view of the above, the present petition is allowed and the challan case of F.I.R. No,124 of 2006 under sections 420/467/468/471, P.P.C. Titled The State v. Muhammad Yasir and others pending in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Section 30, Police Station Talambah, Mianchannu is withdrawn and entrusted to the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Police Station Farid Town, Sahiwal, where another challan case bearing F.I.R. No,139 of 2006, under sections 381-A/411, P.P.C. Titled The State v.
Muhammad Yasir and others is pending.
Case transferred.
Cited by 1 case
- INDEPENDENT MEDIA CORPORATION (PVT.) LTD. through Muhammad Azhar 2019 KLR Criminal Cases 245, 2019 PLD Balochistan 27