DIRECTORGENERAL, ANTICORRUPTION ESTABLISHMENT, LAHORE and others vs MUHAMMAD AKRAM KHAN and others
This appeal by leave of the Court was directed against a Lahore High Court order that partially quashed F.I.R. No. 8 of 2011, registered under Section 409 and 109 P.P.C. read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947, specifically regarding respondent No. 1. The Supreme Court examined whether a High Court could quash an F.I.R. after the trial court had already taken cognizance of the matter. The Court held that partial quashing of an F.I.R. to the extent of specific accused persons is a legal impossibility. Furthermore, the Court reiterated the settled principle that once a trial court takes cognizance following the submission of a Challan, the F.I.R. cannot be quashed. In such circumstances, the accused's remedy lies in seeking premature acquittal under Sections 249-A or 265-K of the Cr.P.C. if the charges are groundless. Consequently, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the High Court's order, directing the accused to pursue statutory remedies before the trial court.
- Section 409, P.P.C.
- Section 109, P.P.C.
- Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947
- sections 249-A/265-K, Cr.P.C.
ORDER
' ASIF SAEED KHAN KHOSA, J.---This appeal by leave of the Court is directed against the order dated 30-9-2011 passed by a learned Judge-in-Chamber of the Lahore High Court, Lahore in Writ Petition No,16970 of 2011 whereby F.I.R. No,8 registered at Police Station Anti-Corruption Establishment, Multan on 27-2-2011 in respect of offences under section 409, P.P.C. Read with section 109, P.P.C. And section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 was partially quashed to the extent of respondent No, 1 .
2. After hearing the learned Additional Advocate-General, Punjab appearing for the appellants and the learned counsel for respondent NO.1 and having gone through the record of the case with their assistance we have found that through the impugned order the learned Judge-in Chamber of the Lahore High Court, Lahore had partially quashed the relevant F.I.R. To the extent of respondent No,1 whereas partial quashing of an F.I.R. To the extent of some of the accused persons mentioned therein is a legal impossibility. Apart from that the impugned order had, been passed by the learned Judge-in-Chamber of the Lahore High Court, Lahore at a time when a Challan in the relevant criminal case had already been submitted before the learned trial court and the learned Trial court had already taken cognizance of the case. The law is quite settled by now that after taking of cognizance of a case by a trial court the F.I.R. Registered in that case cannot be quashed and the fate of the case and of the accused persons challaned therein is to be determined by the trial court itself. It goes without saying that if after taking of cognizance of a case by the trial court an accused person deems himself to be innocent and falsely implicated and he wishes to avoid the rigours of a trial then the law has provided him a remedy under sections 249-/265-K, Cr.P.C. To seek his premature acquittal if the charge against him is groundless or there is no probability of his conviction.
3. For what has been discussed above this appeal is allowed and the impugned order passed by the learned Judge--in-Chamber of the Lahore High Court, Lahore on 30-9-2011 in Writ Petition No,16970 of 2010 is set aside. There shall be no order as to costs.
Cited by 77 cases
- Atta Hussain vs Altaf GouharKhan and others 2025 PHC 152
- Ayesha Tayyab vs Station House Officer, Police Station Cantt. District 2025 SCP 193
- AYESHA TAYYAB Versus STATION HOUSE OFFICER, POLICE STATION CANTT. DISTRICT SIALKOT 2025 SCMR 1117
- NaveeN Jatoi Versus Province of Sindh 2025 PCrLJ 1601
- Jawad Muzaffar vs The State through Advocate General of the State of Azad Jammu and Kashmir Muzafarrabad and 3 others 2024 MLD 1951
- Muhammad Uzair Ahmed Maniya vs Fed. of Pakistan and Others 2024 SHC 878, 2025 PCRLJ 117
- Mohammad Uzair Ahmed Maniya Versus Federation of Pakistan through Chairman/DAG FBR Aqeel Ahmed , Syed Ahsan Ali Shah 2025 PCrLJ 117
- Balqiaz Ali Shah alias Atta vs Wresham Gul & others 2024 PHC 206, 2025 PLD Peshawar 36
- BALQIAZ ALI SHAH alias ATTA ULLAH JAN Versus WRASHEM GUL 2025 PLD 36
- M. Rafique vs FIA through its Director General, Islamabad and others 2024 IHC 174
- Bushra Bibi, Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi vs The State etc. 2024 IHC 5
- Bushra Bibi, Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi vs The State etc, The State & Another 2025 IHC 24
- Imran Ahmed Khan Niazi vs The State, etc. 2023 IHC 150
- Imran Ahmed Khan Niazi, Imran Ahmed Khan Niazi vs The State, etc, Federation of Pakistan, etc 2023 IHC 112, PLJ 2024 Cr.C. 230, 2024 PLD Islamabad 87
- Dr. Shahzad Nasim vs The State & Others 2023 SHC 297
- Usman Zulfiqar Khan vs The State etc. 2022 LHC 6401
- Yasir Shafique vs Station House Officer, Police Station City Muzaffarabad, District Muzaffarabad, Azad Kashmir and 3 others 2022 MLD 1023
- Muhammad Ahmad Zaheer etc vs Federation of Pakistan etc 2022 LHC 6041
- Inayatullah and others vs SHO, FIA Corporate Crime Circle, Islamabad and others 2022 PLJ Islamabad 47
- Inayatullah and others vs Station House Officer, Fia Corporate Crime Circle, Islamabad and others 2022 P Cr. L J 638
- Khurram Iftikhar and Others vs Federation of Pakistan through Secretary, Interior Division, Islamabad and Others 2022 PCRLJ 1665
- FAZAL AMAN Versus SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (SSP), ISLAMABAD 2022 PCrLJN 5
- Faqeer Muhammad vs The State, etc 2021 LHC 829, 2022 KLR Criminal Cases 69, 2022 [M] CLR 126
- Doctor Manzoor Hussain Malik vs The State and another 2021 P Cr. L J 844, 2021 PLJ Lahore 347, 2021 LHC 30
- Abdul Raheem and 2 others vs State and another 2021 PLJ Islamabad 86
- Abdul Raheem and 2 others vs The State and another 2021 PLJ Islamabad 86, 2021 P Cr. L J 882
- Khalid Nadeem Kiyani vs I.G. Police, Islamabad and others 2021 PLJ Islamabad 159, 2021 YLR 728
- Shahid Iqbal and others vs Station House Officer and others 2020 P Cr. L J 1201
- Mst. Sajida Yousuf vs The Director Fia Sindh Karachi and 7 others 2022 MLD 486
- Syed Ghulam raza Shah @Raj Shah vs SSP Jamshor & others 2020 SHC 80
- Hasnain Yaseen vs S.H.O. Police Station Sihala, Islamabad, etc 2020 P Cr. L J 792, 2020 IHC 48
- Mian Haroon Riaz Lucky and another vs The State and others 2021 PLJ SC (Cr.C. ) 250, 2021 SCMR 56
- Syed MUHAMMAD RAZA QAIM RIZVI Versus State 2022 YLRN 7
- MUHAMMAD ALI Versus PROVINCE OF SINDH through Secretary Home Department, Karachi 2022 PCrLJN 42
- SW Sugar Mills Limited through its Chief Executive vs Federal Board of Revenue, Islamabad through its Chairman & others 2020 PTD 925, 2019 PCTLR 947
- ASGHAR ALI Versus ABDUL RAZAQUE 2022 YLRN 33
- MUMTAZUDDIN vs THE STATE 2020 YLR 760, 2020 PTD 129
- ADEEL HANEEF SIDDIQUI Versus State 2022 YLRN 30
- Dr. Ehsan Bari & another vs The State 2018 SHC 738
- MEHMOOD RANGOONWALA and others vs FURQAN ALI MUSTAFA and others 2019 P Cr. L J 1634
- Mir SHAKIL UR RAHMAN and another vs Rai MUHAMMAD ASAD KHAN and another 2019 YLR 157
- RUSTAM KHAN vs The STATE and others 2018 PLD Peshawar 140
- TIANSHI INTERNATIONAL PAKISTAN CO. (PVT.) LTD. Versus FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN 2019 PCrLJN 163
- ZAHEER vs The STATE through D.P.G. and 4 others 2018 YLR 1307
- WALEED KHANZADA Versus State 2017 YLRN 444
- Syed NAYAB HUSSAIN SHERAZI Versus STATION HOUSE OFFICER, POLICE STATION SABZAZAR, LAHORE 2018 PCrLJ 656
- ABDUL QADIR vs PROVINCE OF SINDH through Home Secretary and 3 others 2018 MLD 284
- NADIR ALI KHOSO Versus PROVINCE OF SINDH through Home Secretary, Government of Sindh 2017 YLRN 421
- SADAQAT ALI and another vs DIRECTOR GENERAL FIA, PESHAWAR and others 2018 CLD 835
- ANOOP KUMAR and 3 others vs FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Director 2017 MLD 1402
…and 27 more citing cases