MUHAMMAD SHARIF vs The STATE
This matter arises from a review proceeding before the Supreme Court of Pakistan concerning the sentencing of the petitioner. The core legal question addressed is whether sentences for offences committed as parts of the same transaction, including murder, wrongful confinement, and abduction, ought to run concurrently. The court held that since the offences were parts of the same transaction, the sentences passed for them should ordinarily run concurrently, an aspect that had escaped notice in the original judgment. The review was consequently allowed, and it was ordered that all sentences of imprisonment passed against the petitioner shall run concurrently. The key principle laid down is that sentences for multiple offences committed during the same transaction should generally be ordered to run concurrently.
- Should sentences for offences committed as parts of the same transaction ordinarily run concurrently?
- Can the Supreme Court allow a review to correct an oversight regarding the running of sentences?
- Whether sentences of imprisonment for murder, wrongful confinement, and abduction committed in the same transaction should run concurrently?
ORDER
1. 'ASIF SAEED KHAN KHOSA, J.---The offences committed by the petitioner in respect of murder, wrongful confinement and abduction were parts of the same transaction and, thus, ordinarily the sentences passed for such offences ought to have been ordered to run concurrently to each other.
2. It appears that in the judgment under review this aspect of the matter had escaped the notice of this Court. The Suo Motu Review is, therefore, allowed and it is ordered that all the sentences of imprisonment passed against the petitioner shall run concurrently to each other. Disposed of.
3. Review accepted.
Cited by 7 cases
- Faisal Ansari @ Soni and Qaiser @ Kala vs Province of Sind and others 2025 SHC KHI 2104
- Umar Badshah vs The State and others 2025 PHC 74
- Qadar Khan Versus State 2025 PCrLJ 1723
- Imran Khan Versus State 2025 PCrLJ 1865
- Talib vs Government of Punjab, etc 2022 LHC 1816, 2024 PCRLJ 578, 2022 PLJ Lahore 592
- Hafeez Bibi vs The State & another 2021 PLD Lahore 392, 2021 LHC 477
- LAKHAN alias CHALHO Versus State 2017 PCrLJN 258