HAMOOD MEHMOOD vs Mst. SHABANA ISHAQUE and others
This matter concerned a petition seeking the reversal of a High Court of Sindh judgment dated 23.6.2017, pertaining to specific performance of an agreement. The core legal question addressed was whether a petitioner, who had shown complete defiance to court orders and failed to deposit the balance amount for property sought to be acquired through an agreement, was entitled to relief. The Supreme Court found that the petitioner had not complied with the court's order to deposit the balance amount, even after being given an opportunity. The Court held that it is mandatory for any person, whether plaintiff or defendant, seeking enforcement of an agreement under the Specific Relief Act, 1877, to apply to the Court for permission to deposit the balance amount on first appearance or on the date of institution of the suit. Any contumacious omission in this regard would lead to the dismissal of the suit or its decretal if filed by the other side. Finding no infirmity or illegality in the impugned order, the Supreme Court dismissed the petition and declined leave to appeal.
- Specific Relief Act 1877
ORDER
DOST MUHAMMAD KHAN, J.---The petitioner is seeking reversal of the judgment/order of the High Court of Sindh Karachi dated 23.6.2017.
2. We have gone through the entire record and have found that the petitioner has shown complete defiance to the Court orders albeit the case relates to specific performance of agreement and did not deposit the balance amount. So much so, respondent No.1, at some occasion, requested the trial Court that let another chance be given to him to deposit the balance amount. Although the Court was not inclined to grant such opportunity but even then the petitioner did not comply with the Court's order to deposit the balance amount for the property which he wants to acquire through an agreement.
3. It is mandatory for the person whether plaintiff or defendant who seeks enforcement of the agreement under the Specific Relief Act 1877, that on first appearance before the Court or on the date of institution of the suit, it shall apply to the Court getting permission to deposit the balance amount and any contumacious/omission in this regard would entail in dismissal of the suit or decretal of the suit, if it is filed by the other side.
4. In view of the above legal position to which no exception can be taken we do not see any infirmity much less illegality in the impugned order, therefore, this petition is dismissed and leave to appeal declined.
Cited by 60 cases
- MUHAMMAD IMRAN Versus ISHFAQ AHMED 2026 SCMR 1063
- Naeem Ismail vs Raja Waleed Ur Rehman, etc 2025 IHC 340
- Muhammad Naeem Khan vs Mirza Muhammad Waheed etc 2025 LHC 1327, 2025 PLJ Lahore 621
- Abdul Saeed vs Mrs. Mamooni K. Mohsin Ali Khan, etc 2025 IHC 192
- Haji Idrees vs Haji Nawab Khan Afridi etc. 2024 PHC 272
- Niaz Muhammad vs Muhammad Naveed Khan & others 2024 PHC 244, 2025 PLD Peshawar 21, 2025 PLJ Peshawar 25
- NIAZ MUHAMMAD Versus MUHAMMAD NAVEED KHAN 2025 PLD 21
- Raja Muhammad Khubaib vs Addl. District Judge, Lahore & others 2024 LHC 3171, 2024 CLC 1888
- Ghulam Akhtar vs Muhammad Iqbal 2024 LHC 3055
- Humayon Sajjad vs Aslam Khan 2024 LHC 2268, 2024 YLR 2826
- Meer Gul vs Raja Zafar Mehmood through legal heirs & others 2024 SCP 217, 2024 SCMR 1496
- Sheikh Khalid Javaid vs Shamas ud Din Chishti 2024 LHC 1015, 2024 PLJ Lahore 351, 2025 CLC 513
- Sheikh KHALID JAVAID Versus SHAMAS UD DIN CHISHTI 2025 CLC 513
- Mst. Shamshad Begum and others vs Mohammad Bashir and others 2023 PHC 578
- Syed Muhammad Qasim vs Syed Bashir Ahmed 2024 MLD 1127
- Malik Faisal Mahmood Versus Shahid Ali 2025 YLR 1144
- Ubaid Ullah and others vs Sarfaraz Khan and another 2023 PHC 402, 2024 YLR 2597
- Ishtiaq Saleem vs Syed Zulfiqar Ali Shah (deceased) through L.Rs & others 2023 LHC 2369
- Imtiaz Ahmad vs Muhammad Ashraf (deceased) through L.Rs. and others 2023 YLR 2603
- Mirza Shakeel Ahmed and others vs Atif Tanveer Bhatti and another 2023 PLJ Islamabad 229, 2023 MLD 1715
- Messrs DW Pakistan (Private) Limited, Lahore vs Begum Anisa Fazl-i-Mahmood and others 2023 SCMR 555
- Kabir Hussain vs Arshad Saeed & others 2022 PHC 646
- MUHAMMAD GHAFFAR (DECEASED) Versus ARIF MUHAMMAD 2023 SCMR 344
- Mst. Anayatan BIBI and another vs Maqsood Ahmad and others 2023 PLJ Lahore 259
- Abdus Salam Khan Barki and another vs Mian Pervaiz Akhtar and another 2022 PLD Islamabad 346
- M/s Premium Developers vs Muhammad Tariq 2022 LHC 1890
- PREMIUM DEVELOPERS through Chief Executive Versus MUHAMMAD TARIQ 2023 MLD 838
- Mst. NOOR JEHAN Versus SALEEM SHAHADAT 2022 SCMR 918
- Khairat Ali vs Saqib Ashfaq and others 2023 CLC 926
- Muhammad Zakir vs Muhammad Faisal 2022 SHC 78, 2022 MLD 738
- MUHAMMAD ZAKIR Versus MUHAMMAD FAISAL 2022 MLD 874
- Zulfiqar Ali vs Nisar Ahmad Khateeb and 2 others 2022 CLC 1361
- Irfan Rasheed vs Muhammad Muazim, etc 2021 LHC 5187, 2022 PLD Lahore 372
- Sharafat Ali vs Mst. Shahjahan Begum and another 2021 MLD 1484
- Muhammad Yousaf vs Allah Ditta and others 2021 P SC 1435, 2021 SCMR 1241, 2021 SCP 208
- Muhammad Jamil Babar vs Sara Jalil and 2 others 2021 CLC 1555
- Akhlaq Hashmi vs Mst. Bakht Bibi and 33 others 2021 MLD 1368
- Nasir Mirza vs Syed Muzaffar Ejaz and 2 others 2021 CLC 1399
- Muhammad Asif Awan vs Dawood Khan, etc 2021 P SC 1357, 2021 SCMR 1270, 2021 SCP 238
- Ambreen Moazzam Ali vs Ahmad Zia Ch. etc 2021 LHC 55, 2021 YLR 935
- Muhammad Saddiq and another vs Ghulam Sarwar and 3 others 2021 MLD 2123
- Rana Tahir Hussain vs Additional District Judge, Faisalabad etc 2021 PLJ Lahore 229
- MUHAMMAD JAMIL Versus MUHAMMAD ARIF 2021 SCMR 1108
- Aqeel Feroz vs Shahid Jamil Sethie 2020 MLD 1669, 2020 IHC 112
- Mrs. Anjum Ara vs Shabbir A. Halai 2021 YLR 1476
- Maqsood Ahmad etc vs Amjad Javed 2020 PLJ Lahore 402
- Muhammad Kashif Vohra vs Muhammad Ismail and 3 others 2020 YLR 2024
- Ijaz Ahmad Chaudhry vs Learned Civil Judge, etc 2020 CLC 291, 2020 KLR Civil Cases 15, 2019 LHC 3655
- Mst. Murshida Khatoon vs Ch. Abdul Rehman Sahi and another 2021 MLD 15
- Muhammad Arif Choudhary vs Muzaffar Hussain and others 2019 LHC 2414
…and 10 more citing cases