BOARD OF INTERMEDIATE AND SECONDARY EDUCATION, MULTAN through Chairman and another vs MUHAMMAD SAJID and others
This matter originated from writ petitions filed by daily wage employees of the Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education, Multan, seeking regularization of their services after years of employment. The High Court granted the petitions and dismissed the Board's intra-court appeals. The core legal question before the Supreme Court was whether daily wage workers performing jobs of a permanent nature are entitled to regularization despite artificial breaks in service created by the employer. The Supreme Court dismissed the Board's petitions, holding that the respondents had served for many years and were performing duties of a permanent nature. The Court observed that the practice of hiring workers for 89-day cycles to create artificial breaks in service was a 'clumsy attempt' to deny continuity of service. Following the precedent set in a similar case involving the BISE Rawalpindi, the Court ruled that similarly placed employees must be treated equally. The key principle laid down is that the nature of the job, rather than the nomenclature of the contract or artificial breaks, determines the right to regularization.
ORDER
MAQBOOL BAQAR, J.---Since the respondents, who have been working with the petitioner-Board since last many years on daily wages, were not being regularized by the Board, they filed Writ Petitions before the Lahore High Court which petitions were granted. The Board challenged the said orders through ICAs, which appeals have been dismissed by a learned Division Bench of the High Court.
2. As rightly noted in the impugned judgments, the issue involved in the cases, i,e, regularization of the daily wage workers/contract employees, has already been settled by this Court, through judgment dated 7th March, 2018, in Civil Petition No, 2509/2006, whereby, this Court has upheld judgment dated 7th June, 2016 in terms whereof the Lahore High Court has allowed a similar petition filed by the daily, wage, workers/contract employees of the Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education, Rawalpindi for regularization of their services.
3. It is an admitted position that the respondents before us have been working with the petitioner- Board since long, however, in their clumsy attempt to break the continuity of their service, the petitioner has been employing them for 89 days only, and has been re-hiring them for the next 89 days, and thus continued to avail their service for a long period by creating artificial breaks in their service period. The fact that they have, in fact, continuously served the petitioner for a long period of time, albeit the breaks created by the petitioner, as noted above, clearly shows that they have been performing job of permanent nature and have not been serving on casual posts. Admittedly, similarly placed employees of BISC Rawalpindi, have been regularized in pursuance of the judgment of the High Court, upheld by this Court, as noted above. The learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to highlight a single feature distinguishing the nature of the respondents' job/employment, disentitling them from regularization. The respondents, in the circumstances, were rightly found eligible and entitled for regularization of their service with the petitioner-Board, and have rightly been so ordered through the impugned judgments and we do not find any justification for interfering therewith. The petitions in the circumstances are dismissed.
Cited by 26 cases
- Naeem Hussain & others vs Province of Sindh and others 2025 SHC KHI 2264
- Pakistan International Airlines Corporation Limited vs Full Bench, NIRC and others 2024 PLC 253
- Mumtaz Ali Panhwar & Others vs Province of Sindh & Others 2024 SHC 662, 2024 PLJ Karachi 144, 2024 PLC (C.S.) 1487
- Muhammad Nawaz etc vs M/s. Cadbury Pakistan Ltd., Karachi and others 2025 PLJ Tr.C. (NIRC) 49
- Pakistan International Airlines Corporation vs Sumera Ghaffar and others 2023 IHC 314
- PAKISTAN PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (PWD) through Director General G-9, Islamabad Versus SAJJAD AZIZ, WAITER 2026 PLC 162
- Hasnain Afzal etc vs Government of Punjab etc 2023 LHC 5502
- Syed Ali Kazmi vs Government of Punjab and others 2023 LHC 4856, 2024 PLC (C.S.) 985
- PAKISTAN TELECOMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION LIMITED Versus HUMAYYUN SHAHZAD 2026 PLC 143
- Ali Raza & others vs The Secretary, National Food Security & Research, etc 2022 IHC 14
- Shahnawaz and 36 others vs Province of Sindh through Chief Secretary 2023 PLC (C.S.) 447
- Khalid Mehmood and 128 others vs Federation Of Pakistan through Secretary, Ministry of Information Technology and Telecom and others 2021 PLC (C.S.) 1516
- Riaz Akbar and another vs Federation of Pakistan through Secretary, Establishment Division, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad and 4 others 2021 [M] CLR 1451, 2022 PLC (C.S.) 541
- Secretary, Ministry Of Finance, Islamabad and others vs Tayyaba Halim 2022.PLC (C.S.) 514, 2022 PLC (C.S.) 514
- Secretary, Ministry Of Finance, Islamabad-and others vs Tayyaba Halim 2022 SCMR 77, 2022 PLC (C.S.) 514, 2022 PSC 864
- Board Of Intermediate And Secondary Education, Sahiwal and another vs Akhtar Usman and 2 others 2020 PLC (C.S.) 1036
- SANAULLAH Versus GOVERNMENT OF KHYBER PAKHTUNKHWA through Secretary Higher Education, Civil Secretariat, Peshawar 2021 PLC(CS)N 6
- Maqsood Ahmed & 09 others vs Federation of Pakistan & others 2019 SHC 354
- Asad Akram and Ors vs Fed. of Pakistan and Others 2019 SHC 330
- Province of Punjab through Secretary, Agriculture Department and another 2020 [M] C LR 283
- Hafeez Ahmad and 3 others vs Province Of Punjab through Secretary 2021 PLJ Lahore 778
- Muhammad Rasheed, etc vs Government Of The Punjab through Secretary 2021 PLJ Lahore 191
- Sohail & others vs Pakistan National Shipping 2021 SHC 418
- Board Of Intermediate And Secondary Education, Bahawalpur etc vs Sher 2022 PLJ SC 35
- Secretary, M/o Finance, Islamabad, etc vs DG, FDE, Government Of 2022 PLJ SC 90
- Islamabad Electric Supply Company vs National Industrial Relations 2023 IHC 194, 2024 PCRLJ 944, 2024 PLC 1