1977 PLC 279

DISTRICT MANAGER, SIND ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, KARACHI Versus KHAISTA KHAN

Citation1977 PLC 279

CourtSindh Labour Appellate Tribunal

Case No.Appeal No. KAR‑168 of 1976

Date1976-10-25

Judge(s)Ghulam Rasool Shaikh, Appellate Tribunal DISTRICT MANAGER, SIND ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION, KARACHI

DECISION

This is an appeal against the order of Labour Court ordering reinstatement of the respondent allowing the appellant to hold fresh enquiry.

2. The respondent was a Conductor of a bus and was said to have realized fair from the passengers without issuing tickets. He was charge sheeted and an enquiry was held. He was found guilty and show‑cause notice was given to him. Thereafter, he was dismissed from service. He approached Labour Court under section 25‑A, I. R. O.

3. One of the objections taken by the appellant was that the application made under section 25‑A, was time‑barred. This plea was rejected and it was held that proper opportunity was not allowed to the respondent to defend himself. Consequently, the impugned order was passed.

4. On perusal of the record and proceedings and hearing the arguments I am of the view that the Labour Court erred in holding that the application was not time‑barred. The dismissal order was passed on 3rd October, 1973, whereas the grievance notice was served on 8th May, 1974 and the application under section 25‑A was made on 1st June, 1974. According to section 25‑A the grievance notice had to be served within three months of the cause of action. Obviously in the present case the grievance notice was served after seven months. Delay was sought to be explained on the ground that the respondent had filed an appeal which was decided on 24th December, 1973 and thereafter, filed a mercy petition which was rejected on 5tb April, 1974. So according to the Labour Court period of limitation started from 5th April, 1974 when the mercy petition was rejected. I am unable to uphold this view. There was no provision for mercy petition. At the most the time could be allowed up to the decision of the appeal. But the appeal was decided on 24th December, 1973 and still the grievance notice was sent after about four and a half months.

5. In the circumstances I allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the Labour Court. The application made under section 25‑A stands dismissed.