GHULAM SARWAR Versus MAZHARULLAH
ORDER
1. S.A.NUSRAT, J.- -The respondent filed a suit for rendition of accounts against the petitioners in respect of a partnership firm known as Lyallpur Crockery House. In the said suit, an application was moved under section 34 of the Arbitration Act by the petitioners in view of a clause contained in the partnership deed providing for arbitration. The application was dismissed by the trial Court by order dated 17-6-1984, which was challenged by the petitioners in appeal before the Additional District Judge, who set aside the same by his order dated 12-11-1984. This order, in turn, was challenged by the respondent in revision before the High Court, which was allowed as per impugned order and the order of the first appellate Court was set aside.
2. The main question, which came up for consideration before the High Court, was whether the petitioners, before filing of the application under section 34 of the Arbitration Act, had taken steps in the proceedings and having done so, were not entitled to invoke the arbitration clause and seek stay of the suit.
2. We heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the impugned judgment. The learned High Court, on the basis of the evidence on the record, found that the petitioners had taken steps in the proceedings and as such were not entitled to invoke the arbitration clause and ask for the stay of the suit. The learned counsel for the respondent invited our attention to the order sheet of the trial Court in support of the findings of fact recorded in the impugned order.
3. In our view, no question of law arises in the petition which is dismissed accordingly.
4. M.I./G-56/S Petition dismissed.
Cited by 8 cases
- Malik Khan, etc vs Member (Judicial-VII), Board of Revenue, Punjab, etc 2022 PLJ Lahore 777
- Malik Khan, etc. vs Member (Judicial-VIII), Board of Revenue, Punjab, etc. 2022 LHC 2033
- M/s Gas Drive CNG Services vs Special Judge (Rent), Lahore etc 2020 CLC 871, 2020 PLJ Lahore 103, 2020 LHC 35
- Messrs TRADESMEN INTERNATIONAL (PVT.) LTD. through Chief Executive vs FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Secretary Ministry of Food Agriculture and Livestock and others 2005 MLD 541
- SACHAL MUHAMMAD vs AHMED SAG I-HR SHAHZADA and another 1993 MLD 1066
- NOOR MUHAMMAD vs ALLAH DITTA 1989 MLD 4819
- Malik Khan and others vs Member (Judicial-VIM, Board of Revenue, Punjab 2023 MLD 448
- AL-FARIDIA INDUSTRIES Versus ALFA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD. 1993 MLD 1074