Sheikh RAUF AHMAD Versus Dr. NAZIR SAEED, MEMBER (JUDICIAL-V), BOARD OF REVENUE
1. CH. MUHAMMAD IQBAL, J .---Through this single judgment, I intend to decide titled Writ Petition (W.P.No.96- R/ 2010) along with Writ Petition No.76-R/ 2010, Writ Petition No.136-R/2010 and Writ Petition No.172-R/2010 as common questions of law and facts are involved therein, which are arisen from one consolidated order dated 18.01.2010 whereby the allotment of M. Zaheer Siddique and Mst.Akhtar un Nisa was declared as bogus.
2. W.P.No.96-R/2010
2. Brief facts of the case, as mentioned in the petition are that one Muhammad Zaheer Siddiqui, being a displaced person, was allegedly got allotted evacuee land measuring 91 Kanal 16 Marla comprising Khasra Nos. 1607, 1618, 1620, 1621, 1622, 1629, 1630, 1638, 1639, 1640, 1729, 1730, 1731, 1740 in Moza Amar Sadhu, Lahore vide Khata RL.II No.530 dated 05.05.1971 as Tayyandar. The said alleged allotment was entered in the Jamabandi for the year 1972-1973. He executed a general power of attorney in favour of Sh. Muhammad Farooq, who gifted the said disputed property to his brother/petitioner through gift mutation No.39419 dated 06.01.2003 which was also entered in the revenue record. One Ch. Muhammad Hafeez, Advocate filed application regarding the fake and fraudulent allotment in favour of said Muhammad Zaheer Siddiqui upon which, the inquiry was initiated against the alleged allotment of disputed land to probe the element of fraud. After the inquiry, the Secretary (S&R) Board of Revenue, Punjab directed the District Collector to review the gift mutation No.39419 dated 06.01.2003. The petitioner filed an application to the Chief Minister Punjab who ordered for holding of an inquiry into the matter and the Inquiry Officer recommended for restoration of the aforesaid mutation. The Senior Member, Board of Revenue vide order/letter dated 26.10.2005 constituted a committee for scrutinizing the relevant record. The petitioner filed a Writ Petition No.18199/2005 challenging the above letter dated 23.07.2005 as well as order dated 26.10.2005, and this Court disposed of the writ petition by remanding the matter to the Chief Settlement Commissioner for fresh decision. In the post remand proceedings, the Chief Settlement Commissioner, vide impugned order dated 18.01.2010, declared the allotment of Muhammad Zaheer Siddiqi as well as gift mutation No.39419 dated 06.01.2003, in favour of present petitioner, as illegal, hence this petition.
3. W.P.No.76-R/2010 and W.P. No.136-R/2010
3. Brief facts of the Writ Petition No.76-R/2010 are that Syeda Akhtar-un-Nisa, predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners was alleged allottee of land measuring 176 Kanal in Moza Amar Sadhu, Lahore. The general attorney of the petitioners visited the office of the Halqa Patwari in August, 1984 for obtaining the copies of latest Jamabandi of the said land when it revealed that Muhammad Nawaz and Muhammad Hussain, respondents Nos.3 and 4, had got allotted land measuring 254 Kanal 08 Marla on 10.03.1971 including the Khata of the petitioners in their favour with collusiveness of Settlement staff by inserting a page in RL.II of village Amar Sadhu and on the basis of forgery, they obtained a Robkar for incorporation of said khasra numbers in their favour. Further contended that respondents Nos.3 and 4 sold the land to respondent No.5/ Defence Housing Authority who forcibly got possession of the land from the petitioners. The petitioners filed W.P.No.336-R/1984 before this Court.
4. Syed Moiz Ahmad etc. the petitioners in Writ Petition No.136-R/ 2010 claiming themselves to be the progeny of Hafeez Ahmad, predeceased son of Aziz Ahmad and Mst. Akhtar-un-Nisa have contended that their grandmother Mst. Akhtar un Nisar along with respondents Nod.1 to 6 (of said petition), by excluding the names of the petitioners, filed evacuee claim and got allotted land measuring 176 Kanal in village Amar Sadhu, Lahore against the evacuee claim of their grand-father and petitioners being offspring of predeceased son of Aziz Ahmad are also entitled to the allotment along with other co-sharers. In earlier W.P.No.336 R/1984 filed by Mst. Akhtar-un-Nisa etc. the petitioners filed an application under Order I, Rule 10, C.P.C for their impleading as party which was accepted and they were made party in the said petition. This Court disposed of Writ Petition No.336-R/1984 vide order dated 12.02.2002 and remanded the matter to the Chief Settlement Commissioner/ Notified Officer who vide impugned order dated 18.01.2010 declaring the allotment in favour of the petitioners (Mst. Akhtar-un-Nisa etc) as well as in favour of respondents Nos.3 and 4 as bogus.
4. W.P.No.172-R/2010
5. Through this writ petition, the petitioner/Defence Housing Authority, claiming to be the bona fide purchaser from respondents Nos.2 to 6, has challenged the order dated 18.01.2010, passed by the Chief Settlement Commissioner/ Notified Officer, Punjab whereby the allotment of the respondents Nos.2 to 6/vendors was declared bogus.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the impugned order is without jurisdiction, against the law and facts of the case; that the matter is a past and closed transaction which cannot be reopened; that the Chief Settlement Commissioner has no jurisdiction to pass the impugned order after the repeal of evacuee laws; that the impugned order is non-speaking in nature and passed without application of judicious mind to the facts and law; that no fraud or forgery was committed by the petitioners, as such, the impugned order is illegal and liable to be set aside. Learned counsel for the petitioners placed reliance on a case cited as Javed Akhtar Khan v. DCO/District Collector, Sheikhupura (PLJ 2019 Lahore 647) and submitted that once the allotment has been reflected in the record of rights (Jamabandi) that entry for all intents and purposes is conclusive in nature and settlement as well as revenue authorities are devoid of jurisdiction to investigate the veracity of the said entry.
7. Learned Law Officers appearing on behalf of Settlement Department submit that the Chief Settlement Commissioner has jurisdiction to probe into the matter where any allotment has been obtained through practicing fraud and after perusing the record, the Chief Settlement Commissioner has rightly passed the impugned order which does not require any interference.
8. I have heard the arguments of learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the record with their able assistance.
9. As per record (in W.P.No.96-R/ 2010) one Muhammad Zaheer Siddiqui got allotted disputed land measuring 91 Kanal 16 Marla comprising Khasra Nos.1607, 1618, 1620, 1621, 1622, 1629, 1630, 1638, 1639, 1640, 1729, 1730, 1731, 1740 in Moza Amar Sadhu, Lahore vide Khata RL.II No.530 dated 05.05.1971 as Tayyandar and the said alleged allotment was entered in the Jamabandi for the year 1972-1973. Mst.Akhtar un Nisa etc. the petitioners (in W.Ps.Nos.76-R and 136-R of 2010) claim that disputed land measuring 176 Kanal bearing Khasra Nos. Nos.1625 (14-7), 1624 (10-6), 1619 (8-0), 1616 (14-7), 1615 (10-14), 1614 (5-10), 1646 (3-9), 1645 (15-3), 1644 (5-16), 1628 (3-2), 1627 (4-9), 1626 (6- 17), 1770 (4-01), 1768 (5-4), 1767 (3-2), 1766 (3-2), 1765 (7-8), 1778 (3-4), 1777 (4-0), 1776 (3-9), 1773 (3-11), 1772 (2-10), 1914 (2-6), 1913 (3-1), 1912 (1-9), 1911 (8-19), 1910 (6-12), 1930 (3-7), 1929 (4-9), 1928 (3-4), 1927 (5-4), 1926 (5-10) and 1931 (3-19) was allotted to them on 15.03.1972 against RL.II Khata No.579 in village Amar Sadhu Tehsil and District Lahore against the verified claim of her husband, Syed Aziz Ahmad a displaced person from India.
10. The main controversy in this case which requires determination is whether above said land was got allotted as per law and without any element of fraud. Admittedly the land in question was an evacuee land which conclusively falls in the jurisdiction of the Settlement Authorities. Section 13 of the Displaced Persons Land Settlement Act, 1958 confers jurisdiction upon the Chief Settlement and Rehabilitation Commissioner to declare any evacuee land as a 'building site'. The above provision of law is reproduced as under:
5. "13. Disposal of building sites. Any evacuee land declared by the Chief Settlement Commissioner to be a building site in pursuance of sub-clause (b) of clause (3) of Section 2 shall be disposal of in accordance with the provisions of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1958 and.-
(a) In case the land is situated within the limits of a Municipal Corporation, a Municipal Committee, a Sanitary Committee or a Cantonment, as such limits exist on the commencement of this Act, the sale proceeds thereof shall be credited to the compensation pool constituted under Section 4 of the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1958 (XXVIII of 1958); and
(b) In other cases, the sale proceeds shall be credited to one or more of the compensation pools constituted under Section 5."
6. By exercising the power under the aforementioned provision of law the Chief Settlement and Rehabilitation Commissioner, West Pakistan, Lahore issued a Notification No. 236-66/948-R(L) date 24.02.1966 declaring the certain Khasra Numbers of urban agricultural land in estates of Shahdara, Kot Lakhpat, Dhana Singhwala, and Mouza Amar Sadhu, Lahore as building sites. The scanned copy of the aforesaid notification is reproduced as under:
APPENDIX XI
7. OFFICE OF THE CHIEF SETTLEMENT AND RE-HABILITATION COMMIS-SIONER, WEST PAKISTAN, LAHORE
8. The 24th February, 1966
9. No. 236-66/948-R(L).--- In exercised of the powers conferred upon me under clause (b) of subsection (3) of section 2 of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Act, 1958, I, Dr. S.M. Ikram, S.I., C.S.P., Chief Settlement and Rehabilitation Commissioner, Pakistan do hereby declare the Khasra Nos. (list as under) of urban agricultural land mentioned in the estates situated in the urban area of Lahore as building sites for disposal under section 13 of the said Act.
10. S.M. IKRAM,
11. Chief Settlement and Rehabilitation
12. Commissioner, West Pakistan
NON RATION VILLAGE
1. Shahdara } (PARTIALLY).
2. Kot Lakhpat. }
3. Dhana Singhwala } (IN ENTIRETY)
4. Amar Sidhu }
13. Statement showing the available area in non-rationed village of Shahdara, Kot Lakhpat, Dhana Singhwala, and Amer Sidhu.
14. Serial No.
15. Name of Village
16. Khasra No.
17. Area
18. K.M. Sq. ft.
19. 1.
20. Shahdara .
21. 10
22. 2-16-0
23. 19
24. 4-8-0
25. 29
26. 1-5-0
27. 30
28. 6-12-0
29. 31
30. 8-0-0
31. 32
32. 8-0-0
33. 33
34. 9-0-0
35. 34
36. 8-0-0
37. 35
38. 8-0-0
39. 36
40. 8-0-0
41. 37
42. 8-0-0
43. 38
44. 5-12-0
45. 39
46. 7-12-0
47. 40
48. 7-12-0
49. 41
50. 8-0-0
51. 48/1
52. 6-0-0
53. 40
54. 0-19-0
55. Khasra No.
56. Area
57. Kind of land
58. K.M.
59. 537
60. 2.7
61. Nehri Jhalri
62. 538
63. 8.7
64. "
65. 539
66. 9.14
67. "
68. 540
69. 2.15
70. "
71. 541
72. 8.4
73. "
74. 542
75. 3.11
76. Nehri
77. 545
78. 9.14
79. "
80. 546-min
81. 8.12
82. "
83. 549
84. 11.7
85. "
86. 550-min
87. 4.18
88. "
89. 551-min
90. 3.9
91. "
92. 560-min
93. 2.6
94. "
95. 563
96. 13.6
97. "
98. 564
99. 2.14
100. "
101. 565
102. 5.5
103. "
104. 566
105. 8.16
106. "
107. 567
108. 5.5
109. Banjar Qadim
110. 568
111. 10.8
112. "
113. 569
114. 3.6
115. Nehri
116. 570
117. 7.16
118. "
119. 571
120. 7.2
121. Nehri Jhalari
122. 576-min
123. 2.5
124. Ghair Mumkin Kulri
125. 578-min
126. 0.18
127. Nehri Jhilri
128. 1864.0
4. VILLAGE AMAR SIDHO
129. 19
130. 1.14
131. Nehri
132. 27
133. 0.8
134. Banjar Qadim
135. 2037/37
136. 2.0
137. Houses
138. 49
139. 1.7
140. Tibba
141. 50
142. 2.7
143. "
144. 59
145. 10.12
146. "
147. 60
148. 5.0
149. "
150. 61
151. 17.9
152. "
153. 62
154. 9.16
155. Banjar Qadim
156. 93
157. 3.6
158. Nehri
159. 96
160. 3.1
161. "
162. 99
163. 0.2
164. "
165. 101
166. 4.10
167. Banjar Qadim
168. 120
169. 3.19
170. Tiba
171. 122
172. 0.9
173. Banjar Qadim
174. 131
175. 5.18
176. Nehri
177. 134
178. 6.0
179. "
180. 135
181. 0.11
182. "
183. 142
184. 5.10
185. "
186. 145
187. 3.0
188. "
189. 146
190. 1.19
191. "
192. 162
193. 1.11
194. Khatan
195. 163
196. 2.9
197. "
198. 166
199. 7.0
200. Banjar Qadim
201. 167
202. 13.18
203. Nehri
204. 168
205. 9.16
206. "
207. 169
208. 6.9
209. "
210. 177
211. 4.15
212. "
213. 179
214. 9.17
215. "
216. 180
217. 4.0
218. "
219. 181
220. 5.16
221. "
222. 183
223. 12.1
224. "
225. 184
226. 12.1
227. "
228. 185
229. 13.6
230. "
231. 186
232. 9.15
233. "
234. 187
235. 0.15
236. "
237. 189
238. 1.5
239. "
240. 193
241. 0.12
242. "
243. 196
244. 1.4
245. Banjar Qadim
246. 197
247. 0.8
248. "
249. 198
250. 11.11
251. "
252. 199
253. 11.11
254. "
255. 200
256. 1.17
257. "
258. 201
259. 3.2
260. "
261. 202
262. 8.12
263. Kallar
264. 203
265. 14.15
266. Banjar Qadim
267. 204
268. 4.2
269. "
270. 205
271. 4.16
272. "
273. 206
274. 4.13
275. "
276. 207
277. 6.1
278. "
279. 208
280. 1.6
281. "
282. 209
283. 63.14
284. Kallar
285. 210
286. 4.13
287. Nehri
288. 219
289. 13.12
290. "
291. 220
292. 14.6
293. "
294. 221
295. 4.19
296. "
297. 222
298. 6.12
299. "
300. 223
301. 7.4
302. "
303. 224
304. 10.4
305. "
306. 225
307. 10.4
308. "
309. 226
310. 16.7
311. "
312. 227
313. 6.1
314. "
315. 228
316. 5.13
317. "
318. 229
319. 4.13
320. "
321. 230
322. 3.12
323. "
324. 242
325. 3.7
326. "
327. 243
328. 33.14
329. "
330. 244
331. 7.12
332. "
333. 245
334. 12.0
335. "
336. 246
337. 12.16
338. "
339. 247
340. 14.6
341. "
342. 248
343. 20.7
344. Kallar
345. 249
346. 3.1
347. Nehri
348. 250
349. 5.11
350. "
351. 251
352. 8.13
353. "
354. 252
355. 8.13
356. "
357. 253
358. 7.1
359. "
360. 254
361. 7.8
362. "
363. 255
364. 11.14
365. "
366. 256
367. 10.6
368. Banjar Qadim
369. 257
370. 1.16
371. "
372. 258
373. 0.7
374. "
375. 259
376. 5.17
377. "
378. 260
379. 5.5
380. "
381. 261
382. 5.7
383. "
384. 262
385. 16.9
386. Nehri
387. 263
388. 1.3
389. "
390. 264
391. 1.3
392. "
393. 265
394. 5.17
395. "
396. 266
397. 1.17
398. Nehri
399. 267
400. 1.17
401. "
402. 268
403. 1.2
404. "
405. 269
406. 0.18
407. "
408. 270
409. 15.1
410. "
411. 271
412. 13.15
413. "
414. 272
415. 4.9
416. Banjar Qadim
417. 273
418. 6.7
419. "
420. 274
421. 5.13
422. "
423. 275
424. 0.4
425. Banjar Jadid
426. 276
427. 0.6
428. "
429. 277
430. 1.3
431. "
432. 278
433. 1.7
434. "
435. 279
436. 0.7
437. "
438. 280
439. 1.3
440. Nehri
441. 281
442. 0.12
443. "
444. 282
445. 0.16
446. "
447. 283
448. 1.7
449. Banjar Qadim
450. 284
451. 1.12
452. Nehri
453. 285
454. 2.17
455. Banjar Jadid
456. 286
457. 0.10
458. Banjar Qadim
459. 287
460. 0.10
461. Nehri
462. 288
463. 7.19
464. "
465. 289
466. 11.6
467. "
468. 290
469. 2.1
470. "
471. 292
472. 1.1
473. "
474. 293
475. 2.15
476. "
477. 294
478. 5.3
479. "
480. 295
481. 4.13
482. "
483. 296
484. 4.7
485. "
486. 297
487. 18.0
488. "
489. 298
490. 5.8
491. "
492. 299
493. 0.10
494. "
495. 300
496. 13.3
497. "
498. 301
499. 0.12
500. "
501. 302
502. 6.7
503. "
504. 303
505. 3.9
506. "
507. 304
508. 0.18
509. "
510. 305
511. 2.15
512. "
513. 306
514. 1.6
515. "
516. 307
517. 0.16
518. "
519. 308
520. 1.8
521. Banjar Qadim
522. 309
523. 1.11
524. Nehri
525. 310
526. 0.9
527. "
528. 311
529. 3.18
530. "
531. 312
532. 0.18
533. Banjar Qadim
534. 313
535. 5.0
536. "
537. 314
538. 0.11
539. "
540. 315
541. 1.16
542. "
543. 316
544. 6.10
545. "
546. 318
547. 27.0
548. "
549. 319
550. 4.13
551. Nehri
552. 320
553. 5.0
554. "
555. 321
556. 104
557. Banjar
558. 322
559. 24.10
560. "
561. 323
562. 1.11
563. Nehri
564. 324
565. 0.19
566. "
567. 325
568. 3.19
569. "
570. 326
571. 2.17
572. "
573. 327
574. 2.12
575. "
576. 328
577. 3.8
578. "
579. 329
580. 1.18
581. Banjar Qadim
582. 339
583. 7.9
584. "
585. 340
586. 8.11
587. "
588. 341
589. 7.0
590. "
591. 342
592. 7.9
593. "
594. 343
595. 8.8
596. "
597. 344
598. 6.4
599. "
600. 345
601. 8.12
602. "
603. 346
604. 14.0
605. "
606. 350
607. 30.13
608. "
609. 361
610. 1.16
611. Nehri
612. 365
613. 5.4
614. Banjar Qadim
615. 381
616. 6.13
617. Nehri
618. 445
619. 3.19
620. (Qabaristan 2.19 Banjar Jadid 1.0)
621. 446
622. 11.3
623. Qabaristan
624. 496
625. 0.10
626. Chahi
627. 497
628. 0.18
629. Banjar Qadim
630. 2182/ 650
631. 0.3
632. House
633. 724
634. 1.5
635. Ahata Chah
636. 739
637. 1.9
638. Chahi
639. 751
640. 0.12
641. Nehri
642. 753
643. 3.0
644. Chahi Nehri
645. 764
646. 2.1
647. Nehri
648. 765
649. 3.18
650. "
651. 766
652. 0.10
653. "
654. 770
655. 3.6
656. "
657. 771
658. 1.8
659. "
660. 772
661. 3.2
662. "
663. 773
664. 8.14
665. "
666. 774
667. 4.19
668. "
669. 775
670. 3.18
671. Nehri
672. 779
673. 1.18
674. "
675. 781
676. 8.12
677. "
678. 782-min 7
679. 8.4
680. "
681. 783
682. 4.11
683. "
684. 786
685. 8.12
686. "
687. 791
688. 1.12
689. "
690. 792
691. 8.1
692. "
693. 796
694. 6.19
695. "
696. 799
697. 3.12
698. "
699. 800
700. 3.18
701. "
702. 801
703. 9.6
704. "
705. 811
706. 9.4
707. "
708. 830
709. 4.8
710. "
711. 831
712. 4.5
713. "
714. 832
715. 4.8
716. "
717. 833
718. 7.4
719. "
720. 835
721. 5.6
722. "
723. 836
724. 5.9
725. "
726. 817
727. 3.18
728. "
729. 818
730. 4.1
731. "
732. 846
733. 7.13
734. "
735. 847
736. 7.7
737. "
738. 849-min
739. 2.7
740. Ahata Chah
741. 853
742. 2.4
743. Nehri
744. 884
745. 5.0
746. "
747. 888
748. 3.9
749. "
750. 889
751. 22.15
752. Kallar
753. 890
754. 2.19
755. Nehri
756. 891
757. 6.4
758. G.M. Kallar
759. 892
760. 9.12
761. "
762. 893
763. 3.14
764. "
765. 894
766. 4.15
767. Nehri
768. 895
769. 4.2
770. "
771. 896
772. 2.10
773. "
774. 903-min
775. 3.0
776. "
777. 909
778. 0.5
779. "
780. 915
781. 0.10
782. "
783. 917
784. 0.10
785. "
786. 922
787. 4.13
788. "
789. 928
790. 0.14
791. "
792. 933
793. 2.10
794. "
795. 938
796. 4.14
797. "
798. 949
799. 2.18
800. "
801. 950
802. 2.14
803. "
804. 968
805. 1.5
806. Banjar Qadim
807. 974
808. 7.6
809. Nehri
810. 977
811. 3.0
812. Banjar Qadim
813. 981
814. 0.10
815. G.M. Khatan
816. 990
817. 12.2
818. Nehri
819. 999-min
820. 6.0
821. Banjar Qadim
822. 1001
823. 1.12
824. Nehri
825. 1002
826. 2.10
827. "
828. 1005-min
829. 1.7
830. G.M. Tooba
831. 1006
832. 0.9
833. Barani
834. 1007
835. 4.9
836. G.M. Tooba
837. 1008
838. 13.12
839. "
840. 1009
841. 9.6
842. "
843. 1017
844. 1.0
845. Nehri
846. 1020
847. 1.9
848. Nehri 0.15 G.M. Khal 0.14
849. 1023
850. 0.19
851. Nehri
852. 1037
853. 16.14
854. "
855. 1035
856. 6.0
857. "
858. 1042
859. 7.4
860. "
861. 1046
862. 0.14
863. "
864. 1047
865. 2.4
866. "
867. 1055
868. 4.19
869. G. M. Aar
870. 1056
871. 1.8
872. G.M. Ahata Chah
873. 1057
874. 2.15
875. "
876. 1058
877. 1.10
878. "
879. 1059
880. 1.18
881. "
882. 1060
883. 7.10
884. "
885. 1061
886. 10.14
887. "
888. 1069
889. 6.0
890. Nehri
891. 1070
892. 15.18
893. "
894. 1073
895. 4.13
896. "
897. 1084
898. 0.18
899. "
900. 1085
901. 14.3
902. "
903. 1087
904. 8.4
905. "
906. 1089
907. 0.16
908. "
909. 1090
910. 6.1
911. "
912. 1109
913. 6.10
914. "
915. 1111
916. 0.12
917. "
918. 1164
919. 3.5
920. Ahata Chah
921. 1172
922. 0.12
923. Nehri
924. 1173
925. 6.0
926. "
927. 1174
928. 0.6
929. "
930. 1175
931. 0.3
932. "
933. 1176
934. 0.13
935. "
936. 1177
937. 0.15
938. "
939. 1178
940. 2.4
941. "
942. 1179
943. 1.19
944. "
945. 1184
946. 4.15
947. "
948. 1185
949. 1.14
950. Nehri
951. 1187
952. 10.18
953. "
954. 1188
955. 15.15
956. "
957. 1189
958. 7.2
959. "
960. 1190
961. 9.8
962. "
963. 1191
964. 19.17
965. "
966. 1192
967. 15.10
968. "
969. 1193
970. 3.0
971. Khatan
972. 1194
973. 8.4
974. Nehri
975. 1195
976. 11.15
977. "
978. 1196
979. 15.14
980. "
981. 1197
982. 17.18
983. "
984. 1198
985. 11.11
986. "
987. 1223
988. 17.5
989. "
990. 1225
991. 2.10
992. "
993. 1253
994. 10.18
995. "
996. 1254
997. 1.17
998. "
999. 1255
1000. 8.14
1001. "
1002. 1256
1003. 9.12
1004. "
1005. 1257
1006. 10.3
1007. "
1008. 1258
1009. 10.10
1010. "
1011. 1259
1012. 14.3
1013. "
1014. 1260
1015. 16.8
1016. "
1017. 1273
1018. 1.10
1019. "
1020. 1274
1021. 0.10
1022. "
1023. 1296
1024. 7.4
1025. "
1026. 1297
1027. 10.15
1028. "
1029. 1298
1030. 4.0
1031. "
1032. 1299
1033. 22.0
1034. "
1035. 1300
1036. 8.16
1037. "
1038. 1304
1039. 22.17
1040. "
1041. 1306
1042. 1.6
1043. "
1044. 1309
1045. 21.9
1046. "
1047. 1313
1048. 6.8
1049. "
1050. 1314
1051. 9.1
1052. "
1053. 1315
1054. 6.5
1055. "
1056. 1316
1057. 12.10
1058. "
1059. 1317
1060. 16.9
1061. "
1062. 1318
1063. 2.18
1064. "
1065. 1320
1066. 0.17
1067. "
1068. 1321
1069. 4.1
1070. "
1071. 1322
1072. 21.9
1073. Nehri 14.9 Havaili 7.0
1074. 1323
1075. 3.1
1076. Nehri
1077. 1324
1078. 13.8
1079. "
1080. 1329/1
1081. 0.15
1082. Abadi
1083. 1330
1084. 2.4
1085. Nehri
1086. 1351
1087. 5.2
1088. "
1089. 1354
1090. 9.5
1091. "
1092. 1356
1093. 0.11
1094. "
1095. 1357
1096. 17.7
1097. "
1098. 1358
1099. 13.13
1100. "
1101. 1359
1102. 0.19
1103. Kallar
1104. 1360
1105. 0.4
1106. Barani
1107. 1361
1108. 21.0
1109. "
1110. 1365
1111. 1.1
1112. "
1113. 1366
1114. 5.19
1115. "
1116. 1367
1117. 3.17
1118. "
1119. 1373
1120. 1.0
1121. "
1122. 1380
1123. 9.8
1124. "
1125. 1382
1126. 6.8
1127. "
1128. 1384
1129. 1.17
1130. "
1131. 1385
1132. 8.10
1133. Nehri
1134. 1386
1135. 5.18
1136. "
1137. 1387
1138. 0.19
1139. "
1140. 1388
1141. 6.8
1142. "
1143. 1389
1144. 11.16
1145. "
1146. 1390
1147. 5.14
1148. "
1149. 1391
1150. 10.7
1151. "
1152. 1392
1153. 10.9
1154. "
1155. 1393
1156. 6.6
1157. "
1158. 1394
1159. 9.9
1160. "
1161. 1395
1162. 7.13
1163. "
1164. 1396
1165. 8.12
1166. "
1167. 1397
1168. 11.8
1169. "
1170. 1398
1171. 13.18
1172. "
1173. 1399
1174. 2.3
1175. Barani
1176. 1400
1177. 4.1
1178. "
1179. 1401
1180. 3.14
1181. "
1182. 1402
1183. 1.3
1184. "
1185. 1403
1186. 1.13
1187. "
1188. 1404
1189. 2.7
1190. "
1191. 1405
1192. 5.17
1193. "
1194. 1406
1195. 3.6
1196. "
1197. 1407
1198. 2.2
1199. Nehri
1200. 1408
1201. 3.8
1202. "
1203. 1409
1204. 3.14
1205. "
1206. 1410
1207. 8.12
1208. Kallar
1209. 1411
1210. 8.10
1211. "
1212. 1412
1213. 0.16
1214. G.M. Thoor
1215. 1414
1216. 2.16
1217. "
1218. 1415
1219. 2.16
1220. Banjar Qadim
1221. 1416
1222. 5.18
1223. G.M. Thoor
1224. 1417
1225. 7.18
1226. Kallar
1227. 1418
1228. 4.14
1229. Barani
1230. 1419
1231. 4.14
1232. "
1233. 1420
1234. 1.3
1235. "
1236. 1421
1237. 1.4
1238. "
1239. 1422
1240. 3.15
1241. "
1242. 1423
1243. 6.16
1244. "
1245. 1424
1246. 7.8
1247. "
1248. 1425
1249. 11.4
1250. "
1251. 1426
1252. 5.17
1253. "
1254. 1426/1
1255. 4.8
1256. "
1257. 1427
1258. 14.0
1259. "
1260. 1428
1261. 8.19
1262. "
1263. 1429
1264. 0.16
1265. "
1266. 1430
1267. 4.7
1268. "
1269. 1431
1270. 30.10
1271. "
1272. 1432
1273. 8.11
1274. "
1275. 1433
1276. 6.7
1277. "
1278. 1434
1279. 6.5
1280. "
1281. 1436
1282. 6.19
1283. "
1284. 1435-min
1285. 1.7
1286. "
1287. 1437
1288. 9.17
1289. "
1290. 1438
1291. 10.19
1292. "
1293. 1439
1294. 10.2
1295. "
1296. 1440
1297. 28.9
1298. "
1299. 1441
1300. 17.9
1301. "
1302. 1442
1303. 12.18
1304. "
1305. 1443
1306. 20.5
1307. "
1308. 1444
1309. 26.8
1310. Banjar Jadid
1311. 1445
1312. 14.1
1313. Barani
1314. 1446
1315. 21.19
1316. "
1317. 1447
1318. 12.12
1319. "
1320. 1450
1321. 15.9
1322. "
1323. 1452
1324. 11.12
1325. Nehri
1326. 1453
1327. 3.14
1328. "
1329. 1454
1330. 6.8
1331. "
1332. 1455
1333. 6.8
1334. "
1335. 1457
1336. 4.11
1337. "
1338. 1458
1339. 4.7
1340. "
1341. 1459
1342. 3.4
1343. "
1344. 1460
1345. 4.12
1346. "
1347. 1483
1348. 13.1
1349. "
1350. 1484
1351. 5.12
1352. "
1353. 1485
1354. 2.3
1355. Banjar Qadim
1356. 1486
1357. 2.11
1358. Nehri
1359. 1487
1360. 2.14
1361. "
1362. 1488
1363. 3.4
1364. Banjar Qadim
1365. 1489
1366. 1.18
1367. "
1368. 1490
1369. 6.0
1370. Nehri
1371. 1491
1372. 6.1
1373. "
1374. 1492
1375. 8.17
1376. "
1377. 1493
1378. 8.12
1379. "
1380. 1494
1381. 8.3
1382. "
1383. 1495
1384. 16.4
1385. "
1386. 1496
1387. 2.14
1388. Banjar Qadim
1389. 1497
1390. 15.10
1391. Banjar Jadid
1392. 1498
1393. 11.16
1394. "
1395. 1499
1396. 9.9
1397. "
1398. 1500
1399. 13.4
1400. "
1401. 1501
1402. 10.0
1403. Nehri
1404. 1502
1405. 3.18
1406. Banjar Qadim
1407. 1503
1408. 5.12
1409. G.M. Kallar
1410. 1504
1411. 6.9
1412. Nehri
1413. 1505
1414. 2.14
1415. "
1416. 1506
1417. 6.13
1418. "
1419. 1507
1420. 3.0
1421. "
1422. 1508
1423. 5.16
1424. "
1425. 1509
1426. 3.18
1427. "
1428. 1510
1429. 4.3
1430. "
1431. 1511
1432. 3.16
1433. "
1434. 1512
1435. 7.0
1436. "
1437. 2117/1513
1438. 4.9
1439. "
1440. 2118/151
1441. 8.13
1442. "
1443. 1514
1444. 7.10
1445. "
1446. 1515
1447. 2.3
1448. Banjar Qadim
1449. 1516
1450. 1.6
1451. Nehri
1452. 1617
1453. 1.19
1454. "
1455. 1518
1456. 7.6
1457. G.H. Kallar
1458. 1519
1459. 8.12
1460. "
1461. 1520
1462. 5.8
1463. "
1464. 1521
1465. 3.19
1466. "
1467. 1522
1468. 0.6
1469. "
1470. 1524
1471. 0.12
1472. Barani
1473. 1525
1474. 4.4
1475. "
1476. 1526
1477. 1.4
1478. Banjar Jadid
1479. 1527
1480. 30.11
1481. Barani
1482. 1528
1483. 12.7
1484. "
1485. 1529
1486. 0.9
1487. "
1488. 1530
1489. 7.16
1490. "
1491. 1531
1492. 8.12
1493. Banjar Qadim
1494. 1532
1495. 12.19
1496. Barani
1497. 1533
1498. 8.0
1499. "
1500. 1534
1501. 0.12
1502. "
1503. 1535
1504. 14.9
1505. Barani
1506. 1536
1507. 0.18
1508. "
1509. 1537
1510. 26.8
1511. "
1512. 1538
1513. 18.17
1514. "
1515. 1539
1516. 9.3
1517. "
1518. 1540
1519. 16.14
1520. "
1521. 1541
1522. 28.9
1523. "
1524. 1542
1525. 23.2
1526. "
1527. 1543
1528. 16.4
1529. "
1530. 1544
1531. 0.16
1532. "
1533. 1545
1534. 9.1
1535. "
1536. 1546
1537. 8.10
1538. "
1539. 1547
1540. 10.16
1541. "
1542. 1548
1543. 9.8
1544. "
1545. 1549
1546. 4.11
1547. "
1548. 1550
1549. 3.8
1550. "
1551. 1551
1552. 4.12
1553. "
1554. 1552
1555. 1.18
1556. "
1557. 1553
1558. 12.4
1559. "
1560. 1554
1561. 3.2
1562. "
1563. 1555
1564. 2.13
1565. "
1566. 1556
1567. 4.3
1568. "
1569. 1557
1570. 5.11
1571. "
1572. 1558
1573. 7.13
1574. "
1575. 1559-min
1576. 5.3
1577. "
1578. 1560
1579. 5.3
1580. Nehri
1581. 1561
1582. 5.1
1583. "
1584. 1562
1585. 4.10
1586. Barani
1587. 1563
1588. 3.4
1589. "
1590. 1564
1591. 4.2
1592. "
1593. 1565
1594. 2.0
1595. "
1596. 1566
1597. 2.0
1598. "
1599. 1567
1600. 6.16
1601. "
1602. 1568
1603. 9.4
1604. "
1605. 1569
1606. 12.0
1607. "
1608. 1570
1609. 9.14
1610. "
1611. 1571
1612. 1.16
1613. "
1614. 1572
1615. 14.9
1616. "
1617. 1573
1618. 6.19
1619. "
1620. 1574
1621. 5.19
1622. "
1623. 1575
1624. 6.8
1625. "
1626. 1576
1627. 29.9
1628. "
1629. 1577
1630. 9.6
1631. "
1632. 1578
1633. 6.0
1634. "
1635. 1579
1636. 4.0
1637. "
1638. 1580
1639. 4.11
1640. "
1641. 1581
1642. 8.8
1643. "
1644. 1582
1645. 5.9
1646. Barani
1647. 1583
1648. 2.4
1649. Banjar Jadid
1650. 1584
1651. 2.12
1652. Chahi
1653. 1585
1654. 7.4
1655. "
1656. 1586
1657. 5.18
1658. "
1659. 1587
1660. 3.8
1661. "
1662. 1588
1663. 2.19
1664. "
1665. 1589
1666. 1.9
1667. "
1668. 1590
1669. 3.18
1670. "
1671. 1591
1672. 10.2
1673. "
1674. 1592
1675. 2.3
1676. "
1677. 1593
1678. 15.10
1679. "
1680. 1594
1681. 10.19
1682. "
1683. 1595
1684. 10.2
1685. "
1686. 1596
1687. 12.5
1688. "
1689. 1597
1690. 5.5
1691. Barani
1692. 1598
1693. 6.2
1694. "
1695. 1599
1696. 8.2
1697. "
1698. 1600/1601
1699. 4.7
1700. "
1701. 1602
1702. 2.16
1703. "
1704. 1603
1705. 3.7
1706. "
1707. 1604
1708. 30.1
1709. "
1710. 1605
1711. 6.19
1712. "
1713. 1606
1714. 7.8
1715. "
1716. 1607
1717. 6.8
1718. "
1719. 1608
1720. 9.8
1721. 1609
1722. 14.7
1723. Chahi
1724. 1610
1725. 7.10
1726. "
1727. 1611
1728. 4.2
1729. "
1730. 1612
1731. 8.4
1732. "
1733. 1613
1734. 8.2
1735. "
1736. 1614
1737. 5.10
1738. "
1739. 1615
1740. 10.14
1741. "
1742. 1616
1743. 14.7
1744. "
1745. 1617
1746. 29.6
1747. "
1748. 1618
1749. 19.7
1750. "
1751. 1619
1752. 8.0
1753. "
1754. 1620
1755. 10.12
1756. "
1757. 1621
1758. 5.16
1759. "
1760. 1622
1761. 5.7
1762. "
1763. 1623
1764. 6.13
1765. "
1766. 1624
1767. 10.6
1768. "
1769. 1625
1770. 7.7
1771. "
1772. 1626
1773. 6.17
1774. "
1775. 1627
1776. 4.9
1777. "
1778. 1628
1779. 3.2
1780. "
1781. 1629
1782. 9.13
1783. "
1784. 1630
1785. 2.6
1786. Barani
1787. 1631
1788. 7.18
1789. 1632
1790. 3.0
1791. 1633
1792. 3.10
1793. 1634
1794. 2.2
1795. Kallar
1796. 1635
1797. 3.7
1798. Banjar Qadim
1799. 1636
1800. 7.1
1801. "
1802. 1637
1803. 2.14
1804. "
1805. 1638
1806. 3.16
1807. Nehri
1808. 1639
1809. 4.13
1810. "
1811. 1640
1812. 5.13
1813. "
1814. 1641
1815. 12.12
1816. Banjar Qadim
1817. 1642
1818. 10.3
1819. "
1820. 1643
1821. 2.10
1822. "
1823. 1644
1824. 5.14
1825. "
1826. 1645
1827. 15.13
1828. Banjar Jadid
1829. 1646
1830. 3.9
1831. Chahi
1832. 1647
1833. 3.19
1834. "
1835. 1648
1836. 8.0
1837. "
1838. 1649
1839. 6.9
1840. "
1841. 1649/1
1842. 7.0
1843. "
1844. 1650
1845. 5.0
1846. "
1847. 1651
1848. 7.9
1849. "
1850. 1652
1851. 6.14
1852. "
1853. 1653
1854. 5.17
1855. "
1856. 1654
1857. 5.16
1858. "
1859. 1655
1860. 2.0
1861. "
1862. 1656
1863. 4.12
1864. "
1865. 1657
1866. 6.15
1867. "
1868. 1658
1869. 2.17
1870. "
1871. 1659
1872. 9.9
1873. "
1874. 1660
1875. 6.14
1876. "
1877. 1661
1878. 15.4
1879. "
1880. 1666
1881. 2.18
1882. "
1883. 1667
1884. 1.15
1885. Chahi 1.13 Ghair Mumkin 2
1886. 1668
1887. 10.13
1888. Chahi
1889. 1669
1890. 2.5
1891. "
1892. 1670
1893. 2.8
1894. "
1895. 1671
1896. 3.9
1897. "
1898. 1672
1899. 5.0
1900. Barani
1901. 1673
1902. 1.1
1903. Chahi
1904. 1674
1905. 2.0
1906. Barani
1907. 1675
1908. 2.6
1909. "
1910. 1676
1911. 4.4
1912. "
1913. 1677
1914. 8.8
1915. "
1916. 1678
1917. 2.12
1918. "
1919. 1679
1920. 7.5
1921. Banjar Qadim
1922. 1680
1923. 4.77
1924. Chahi
1925. 1681
1926. 4.15
1927. "
1928. 1682
1929. 10.13
1930. "
1931. 1683
1932. 2.9
1933. "
1934. 1684
1935. 1.2
1936. Banjar Qadim
1937. 1685
1938. 2.10
1939. "
1940. 1686
1941. 46.16
1942. "
1943. 1687
1944. 2.16
1945. "
1946. 1688
1947. 15.4
1948. "
1949. 1689
1950. 5.18
1951. "
1952. 1690
1953. 8.5
1954. Chahi
1955. 1691
1956. 0.8
1957. "
1958. 1692
1959. 3.12
1960. "
1961. 1693
1962. 9.2
1963. "
1964. 1694
1965. 35.9
1966. Banjar Qadim
1967. 1695
1968. 2.7
1969. Barani
1970. 1696
1971. 3.7
1972. "
1973. 1697
1974. 14.1
1975. Nehri
1976. 1698
1977. 7.3
1978. Banjar Qadim
1979. 1699
1980. 7.17
1981. Nehri
1982. 1700
1983. 6.14
1984. "
1985. 1701
1986. 5.15
1987. "
1988. 1702
1989. 6.4
1990. "
1991. 1703
1992. 2.16
1993. "
1994. 1704
1995. 1.13
1996. "
1997. 1705
1998. 1.4
1999. "
2000. 1706
2001. 2.18
2002. "
2003. 1707
2004. 4.0
2005. "
2006. 1708
2007. 0.16
2008. "
2009. 1709
2010. 3.10
2011. "
2012. 1711
2013. 5.12
2014. "
2015. 1712
2016. 10.10
2017. "
2018. 1713
2019. 8.10
2020. "
2021. 1714
2022. 7.7
2023. "
2024. 1715
2025. 7.18
2026. "
2027. 1716
2028. 9.2
2029. "
2030. 1717
2031. 7.2
2032. "
2033. 1718
2034. 9.9
2035. "
2036. 1719
2037. 1.0
2038. "
2039. 1724
2040. 0.19
2041. "
2042. 1725
2043. 1.1
2044. "
2045. 1727
2046. 4.18
2047. "
2048. 1728
2049. 3.8
2050. "
2051. 1729
2052. 4.4
2053. "
2054. 1730
2055. 4.2
2056. "
2057. 1731
2058. 5.19
2059. "
2060. 1732
2061. 7.8
2062. "
2063. 1733
2064. 3.5
2065. Nehri
2066. 1734
2067. 6.13
2068. "
2069. 1735
2070. 0.9
2071. "
2072. 1736
2073. 2.11
2074. "
2075. 1737
2076. 5.15
2077. "
2078. 1738
2079. 4.14
2080. "
2081. 1739
2082. 2.12
2083. Banjar Qadim
2084. 1740
2085. 4.0
2086. "
2087. 1741
2088. 6.13
2089. Thoor
2090. 1742
2091. 3.10
2092. "
2093. 1743
2094. 1.12
2095. "
2096. 1746
2097. 2.2
2098. Nehri
2099. 1747
2100. 2.19
2101. "
2102. 1748
2103. 3.13
2104. "
2105. 1749
2106. 4.0
2107. "
2108. 1752
2109. 4.5
2110. "
2111. 1753
2112. 9.16
2113. "
2114. 1754
2115. 3.12
2116. "
2117. 1756
2118. 3.7
2119. "
2120. 1757
2121. 2.0
2122. "
2123. 1758
2124. 2.2
2125. "
2126. 1759
2127. 4.12
2128. "
2129. 1760
2130. 5.7
2131. "
2132. 1761
2133. 4.0
2134. "
2135. 1765
2136. 4.8
2137. "
2138. 1766
2139. 3.2
2140. "
2141. 1767
2142. 3.4
2143. "
2144. 1768
2145. 5.4
2146. "
2147. 1769
2148. 3.5
2149. "
2150. 1770
2151. 4.1
2152. "
2153. 1771
2154. 2.12
2155. "
2156. 1772
2157. 2.10
2158. "
2159. 1773
2160. 3.11
2161. "
2162. 1774
2163. 2.2
2164. "
2165. 1775
2166. 1.12
2167. "
2168. 1776
2169. 3.2
2170. "
2171. 1777
2172. 3.2
2173. "
2174. 1778
2175. 4.0
2176. "
2177. 1782
2178. 4.15
2179. Chahi Nehri
2180. 1783
2181. 4.10
2182. "
2183. 1784
2184. 2.3
2185. "
2186. 1785
2187. 4.4
2188. "
2189. 1786
2190. 1.14
2191. "
2192. 1787
2193. 2.17
2194. "
2195. 1788
2196. 3.18
2197. "
2198. 1789
2199. 1.4
2200. "
2201. 1790
2202. 1.4
2203. "
2204. 1791
2205. 1.2
2206. Chahi Nehri
2207. 1792
2208. 1.2
2209. "
2210. 1793
2211. 2.7
2212. "
2213. 1794
2214. 2.7
2215. "
2216. 1795
2217. 2.14
2218. "
2219. 1796
2220. 4.19
2221. "
2222. 1797
2223. 4.2
2224. "
2225. 1799
2226. 1.18
2227. Nehri
2228. 1800
2229. 1.8
2230. Chahi Nehri
2231. 1801
2232. 2.17
2233. Nehri
2234. 1806
2235. 2.0
2236. G.M. Ahata Chah
2237. 1821
2238. 1.2
2239. Nehri
2240. 1824
2241. 2.4
2242. "
2243. 1826 min
2244. 0.5
2245. "
2246. 1840
2247. 4.6
2248. "
2249. 1841
2250. 7.14
2251. "
2252. 1843
2253. 2.3
2254. "
2255. 1844
2256. 2.3
2257. Chahi Nehri
2258. 1845
2259. 4.14
2260. "
2261. 1846
2262. 5.8
2263. Nehri
2264. 1847
2265. 4.15
2266. "
2267. 1848
2268. 4.0
2269. Chahi Nehri
2270. 1849
2271. 2.5
2272. "
2273. 1850
2274. 3.0
2275. "
2276. 1851
2277. 5.2
2278. "
2279. 1852
2280. 4.12
2281. "
2282. 1853
2283. 2.18
2284. "
2285. 1854
2286. 3.0
2287. "
2288. 1855
2289. 5.2
2290. "
2291. 1856
2292. 5.14
2293. "
2294. 1857
2295. 6.0
2296. Nehri
2297. 1858
2298. 7.16
2299. Chahi Nehri
2300. 1859
2301. 6.10
2302. Nehri
2303. 1860
2304. 4.0
2305. "
2306. 1864
2307. 1.15
2308. Ghair Mumkin
2309. 1865
2310. 1.0
2311. Chahi Nehri
2312. 1866
2313. 2.10
2314. "
2315. 1868
2316. 5.12
2317. "
2318. 1869
2319. 3.19
2320. "
2321. 1870
2322. 6.0
2323. Chahi
2324. 1871
2325. 4.14
2326. "
2327. 1872
2328. 4.5
2329. "
2330. 1873
2331. 1.1
2332. "
2333. 1874
2334. 2.2
2335. "
2336. 1875
2337. 2.9
2338. "
2339. 1876
2340. 8.12
2341. "
2342. 1877
2343. 2.0
2344. "
2345. 1878
2346. 2.5
2347. Chahi
2348. 1879
2349. 2.2
2350. "
2351. 1880
2352. 1.12
2353. "
2354. 1881
2355. 1.9
2356. "
2357. 1882
2358. 3.0
2359. "
2360. 1888
2361. 1.8
2362. Thoor
2363. 1889
2364. 0.19
2365. "
2366. 1890
2367. 1.5
2368. Ghair Mumkin
2369. 1891
2370. 1.19
2371. Chahi
2372. 1892
2373. 2.18
2374. "
2375. 1894
2376. 0.17
2377. Chahi
2378. 1995
2379. 0.16
2380. "
2381. 1896
2382. 1.0
2383. "
2384. 1897
2385. 3.18
2386. Chahi
2387. 1898
2388. 7.14
2389. "
2390. 1899
2391. 2.2
2392. "
2393. 1900
2394. 0.17
2395. Ghair Mumkin
2396. 1902
2397. 17.9
2398. "
2399. 1903
2400. 12.17
2401. "
2402. 1907
2403. 3.11
2404. Chahi
2405. 1909
2406. 6.0
2407. Nehri
2408. 1910
2409. 6.12
2410. "
2411. 1911
2412. 5.19
2413. "
2414. 1912
2415. 1.19
2416. "
2417. 1913
2418. 3.8
2419. "
2420. 1914
2421. 2.6
2422. "
2423. 1915
2424. 3.4
2425. "
2426. 1916
2427. 7.4
2428. "
2429. 1917
2430. 4.0
2431. "
2432. 1918
2433. 4.9
2434. "
2435. 1919
2436. 6.4
2437. "
2438. 1920
2439. 4.14
2440. "
2441. 1921
2442. 8.15
2443. "
2444. 1922
2445. 2.8
2446. "
2447. 1923
2448. 2.15
2449. "
2450. 1925
2451. 0.19
2452. "
2453. 1926
2454. 5.10
2455. "
2456. 1927
2457. 5.4
2458. "
2459. 1928
2460. 3.4
2461. "
2462. 1929
2463. 4.6
2464. "
2465. 1930
2466. 3.7
2467. "
2468. 1931
2469. 2.12
2470. "
2471. 1935
2472. 8.0
2473. "
2474. 1936
2475. 5.15
2476. "
2477. 1937
2478. 5.0
2479. "
2480. 1938
2481. 1.0
2482. "
2483. 1939
2484. 4.0
2485. Nehri
2486. 1940
2487. 11.19
2488. "
2489. 1941
2490. 5.8
2491. "
2492. 1942
2493. 4.18
2494. "
2495. 1943
2496. 6.10
2497. "
2498. 1944
2499. 6.13
2500. "
2501. 1945
2502. 6.2
2503. "
2504. 1946-min
2505. 9.4
2506. "
2507. 1947
2508. 2.6
2509. "
2510. 1948
2511. 7.2
2512. "
2513. 1949
2514. 0.12
2515. "
2516. 1950
2517. 0.18
2518. "
2519. 1951
2520. 0.7
2521. "
2522. 1952
2523. 8.14
2524. "
2525. 1953
2526. 4.0
2527. "
2528. 1955
2529. 6.16
2530. "
2531. 1956
2532. 0.6
2533. "
2534. 1956
2535. 1.17
2536. "
2537. 1957
2538. 4.15
2539. Chahi Nehri
2540. 1958
2541. 4.14
2542. "
2543. 1960
2544. 4.4
2545. "
2546. 1961
2547. 3.1
2548. "
2549. 1962
2550. 8.14
2551. "
2552. 1963
2553. 3.17
2554. "
2555. 1964
2556. 1.5
2557. "
2558. 1965
2559. 1.18
2560. "
2561. 1966
2562. 1.12
2563. "
2564. 1967
2565. 4.3
2566. "
2567. 1968
2568. 2.5
2569. Thoor
2570. 1969
2571. 1.19
2572. Nehri
2573. 1971
2574. 0.5
2575. Thoor
2576. 1972
2577. 1.5
2578. Chahi
2579. 1973
2580. 1.19
2581. "
2582. 1974
2583. 5.14
2584. "
2585. 1975
2586. 3.5
2587. "
2588. 1976
2589. 3.4
2590. "
2591. 1977
2592. 3.2
2593. "
2594. 1978
2595. 3.8
2596. "
2597. 1979
2598. 2.8
2599. "
2600. 1980
2601. 2.16
2602. Nehri
2603. 1981
2604. 4.3
2605. "
2606. 1982
2607. 2.5
2608. 1985
2609. 3.16
2610. "
2611. 1986
2612. 4.0
2613. "
2614. 1987
2615. 5.4
2616. "
2617. 1988
2618. 1.10
2619. Chahi Nehri
2620. 1989
2621. 29.4
2622. "
2623. 1990
2624. 2.0
2625. "
2626. 1991
2627. 3.18
2628. Nehri
2629. 1992
2630. 5.17
2631. "
2632. 1993
2633. 24.1
2634. "
2635. 1994
2636. 21.6
2637. "
2638. 1995
2639. 4.6
2640. "
2641. 1996
2642. 4.4
2643. Thoor
2644. 1997
2645. 13.11
2646. "
2647. 1998
2648. 6.0
2649. Nehri
2650. 1999
2651. 9.16
2652. "
2653. 2000
2654. 25.14
2655. Thoor
2656. 2001
2657. 14.14
2658. "
2659. 2002
2660. 0.18
2661. "
2662. 2003
2663. 3.6
2664. 2004
2665. 1.16
2666. "
2667. 2005
2668. 5.2
2669. "
2670. 2009
2671. 3.0
2672. Banjar Qadim
2673. 2010
2674. 1.0
2675. G.M. Jhappar
2676. 2011
2677. 8.7
2678. Chahi
2679. 2012
2680. 4.17
2681. Banjar Jadid
2682. 2013
2683. 1.8
2684. "
2685. 2014
2686. 8.7
2687. Abadi
2688. 2015
2689. 3.16
2690. Banjar Qadim
2691. 2016
2692. 3.14
2693. "
2694. 2017
2695. 7.1
2696. G.M. Havaili
2697. 2018
2698. 0.18
2699. Banjar Qadim
2700. 2019
2701. 2.0
2702. "
2703. 2020
2704. 1.0
2705. "
2706. 2021
2707. 0.7
2708. "
2709. 2022
2710. 2.3
2711. G.M. Jhappar
2712. 2023
2713. 6.1
2714. "
2715. 2024
2716. 2.2
2717. Banjar Qadim
2718. 2025
2719. 7.0
2720. "
2721. 2026
2722. 3.6
2723. "
2724. 2027
2725. 7.6
2726. "
2727. 2028
2728. 14.19
2729. "
2730. 2029
2731. 4.7
2732. G.M. Jhappar
2733. 2030
2734. 2.8
2735. "
2736. 2034
2737. 2.6
2738. "
2739. Total
2740. 5353-2-0
2741. With issuance of the above notification the evacuee land situated in Amar Sadhu was also treated being a 'building site' which stood excluded from the compensation pool constituted under Section 4 of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Act, 1958 and was not available for allotment against any urban or rural agriculture claim. The above said notification was still in vogue when the Chief Settlement Commissioner in exercise of power so vested with him in section 2 of clause (b) and sub-clause (3) of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement), Act 1958 issued another notification dated 16.05.1973 declaring all the agricultural lands falling within the Municipal Limits etc. as 'Building Site' restraining his subordinate settlement authorities to make any fresh allotment without approval of the competent authority. The said notification is reproduced hereunder:-
2742. "In exercise of powers conferred upon me under clause (b) of subsection (3) of section 2 of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Act, 1958, IO, Mr. M. Aslam Awais, C.S.P., Chief Settlement and Rehabilitation Commissioner, Punjab do hereby declare all the available evacuee urban land, including the one not yet confirmed to any person against units or evacuee land which may become available in future, in all the Revenue Estates situated within the Urban limits of a Municipal Corporation, Municipal Committee, Notified Area Committee, Town Area Committee, Small Town Committee and Sanitary Committee, or a Cantonment, throughout the Province of Punjab, as building sites, for disposal under section 13 of the said Act. "
2743. Since the promulgation of Notification dated 24.02.1966 treating the urban properties of Mouza Amar Sadhu as building site, there was no occasion with the Settlement authorities to make any allotment of said land in violation of above notifications. Moreover the above notifications were still in field as the same were neither withdrawn by the authorities nor were set aside by any competent forum in this regard. Moreover, the Settlement Laws were stood repealed with effect from 01.07.1974 with promulgation of Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act, 1975 and under Section 2(2) of the said Act jurisdiction of Notified Officer was restricted only to the proceedings immediately pending before the repealing Act or the matter remanded by this or the Hon'ble Supreme Court. A modus operandi furnished in Section 3 of the Act regarding the disposal of the urban land under a policy to be framed by the Government in this regard.
2744. For the disposal of urban evacuee properties/ buildings sites, the Provincial Government promulgated scheme 1977 under Section 3 of the Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act, 1975 for the Management and Disposal of Available Urban Properties situated in the Province of the Punjab in 1977 (The Scheme, 1977). Para 1 (d) of the Scheme i bid, contains the definition of Building Site which is reproduced as under:--
2745. "Building Site" means any vacant plot of land which is not within a well-defined compound of a permanent building and includes:--
(i) A site on which the permanent construction, if any, does not exceed in area by 1/8th of the site;
(ii) any site on which any building existed but was completely demolished by floods, fire, incendiary or by any natural calamity.
2746. From the perusal of the Evacuee Properties and Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act No. XIV of 1975 as well as paras 6, 11, 12 and 30 of Scheme 1977, a building site should only be disposed of through an unrestricted public auction in terms of Para-11 of the Scheme 1977 ibid. Admittedly all the evacuee land vest with the provincial government against the paid consideration and attained the status of public properties and public functionaries are the trusty/custodians of the public/ State land which land could only be disposed of in accordance with law and most transparent and suitable modus operandi which better serve the case is putting such property to public auction. Reliance is placed on the case titled as Muhammad Ramzan and others v. Member (Revenue) Chief Settlement Commissioner and others (1997 SCMR 1635) wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of Pakistan held as under:-
2747. "18. The Government of the Punjab Province then prepared and prescribed Scheme for the management and disposal of available urban properties (See PLD 1977 Punjab Statute page 62). Certain provisions of the Scheme were amended in 1985 (See PLD 1985 Punjab Statute page 6). The terms "available properties" and "building sites" were defined in paragraphs 1 (c) and 1(d) of the Scheme, 1977. Paragraph 6 provided that an available building site on which a person in possession has raised a permanent construction and applied for its transfer may be transferred to him along with an area which does not exceed three times the constructed area on the transfer price and where any person having made a permanent construction on a building site did not apply for transfer, it should be disposed of through unrestricted public auction along with the construction. The value of such construction shall be determined by the Deputy Administrator and paid to such a person out of the auction proceeds by such authority as may be specified. Paragraph 11 of the Scheme also provides for auction of the building site."
2748. (emphasis supplied)
2749. The vires of the above notification dated 16.05.1973 were assailed by different persons but finally it came under judicial scrutiny before the August Supreme Court and said notification was upheld in case reported as Muhammad Ramzan and others v. Member (Rev.)/CSS and others (1997 SCMR 1635) whereas after the Repealing Act, 1975 there exists no agricultural urban land in Moza Amar Sadhu, Lahore for any allotment or adjustment against unsatisfied claims of produce index units and the claimants holding any unsatisfied entitlement pending PIUs may seek any other remedy if available under the law, whereas they stood disentitled to obtain allotment of urban land in satisfaction of pending units or get alternate allotment of land. Admittedly the land of revenue estate of village Amar Sadhu, Lahore definitely falls within the ambit of the Notification dated 24.02.1966 as well as 16.05.1973 whereby the Chief Settlement Commissioner has already declared it as 'building site' leaving no space for any allotment of said land to any claimant and if any allotment has been obtained in contravention of the above notification that would be illegal and void ab initio.
10. Now adverting to the allotment of M. Zaheer Siddique, it evinces from the record appended with instant petition (W.P.No.96-R/2010), that land measuring 91 Kanal 16 Marla, Mouza Amar Sadhu, Lahore was allegedly allotted to him on 30.03.1971 as Tayyandar, whereas according to the available revenue record, the Provincial Government is shown owner of the disputed land and the Chief Settlement Commissioner is in possession of the same. Similarly the Register Haqdaran Zameen for the year 1968-69 reflects the ownership of the Central Government over the suit land and Muhammad Munir son of Labhu, Allah Ditta son of Jan Muhammad and Mahar Din were entered as ghair dakheelkar and the cultivation possession was with Sher Muhammad son of Jahania. As per the copy of Register Haqdaran Zameen for the year 1972-1973, appended with this petition, the name of Muhammad Zaheer Siddique is shown entered as Tayyandar without any reference to the foundational order of the competent authority whereby he was determined as Tayyandar and no other document was produced before this Court to show the validly made allotment of the said land as a tayyandar in his favour, as such he was not holding any absolute allotment confirming any title upon him. Admittedly, there is no any allotment order is attached with the petition passed by any competent authority in favour of petitioners, but learned counsel for the petitioners vehemently argued that only the entry of ownership reflected in Jamabandi is sufficient compliance of law and non-sanctioning of mutation is inconsequential, suffice it to say in this regard that the entry in the record must have been recorded on the basis of foundational order of allotment passed by the competent authority whereas mere any entry in the record of right without existence of any order of competent authority carry no significance. I have perused the copies of Jamabandi for the years 1972-1973 appended with this petition and in the column of ownership (column No.3), the land is still shown in ownership of the Central Government whereas the names of petitioners is written in the column No.4 meant to show the possession of cultivator and there is no any copy of Jamabandi placed on record to show that the names of the petitioners/the alleged allottees, were written in the column of ownership (column No.3). There is no any mutation is available on record in favour of the alleged allottee sanctioned in respect of transfer of ownership right (tabdeeli hakoq-e-malkiyat). The entire record of all the RL.IIs were sealed on 16.05.1973 under the order of competent authority due to imposition of complete ban on the further allotment on account of declaration of all the urban agricultural land as building sites which factum oust the possibility of any allotment at Khata RL-II in favour of any claimant namely M. Zaheer Siddique and his allotment was patently illegal.
2750. So far as the case of Akhtar un Nisa etc. is concerned (W.Ps. Nos.76-R of 2010 and 136-R of 2010) the petitioners claimed to be the allottees of land measuring 176 Kanals in Mauza Amar Sidhu against the evacuee claim of Aziz Ahmad, their predecessor in interest, suffice it to say that a s per the available record, the suit land was allegedly allotted by Additional Settlement Commissioner, Lahore on 20.07.1970 which was confirmed on 10.03.1971 at Khata RL.II No.582 in the name of one Muhammad Nawaz Khan but Akthar-un-Nisa etc. claimed the allotment of said land on 01.07.1971 and its confirmation in their favour on 15.03.1972, whereas after the allotment of said land to Muhammad Nawaz Khan etc. the land wen out of the settlement pool and was not available for any further allotment to Mst. Akhtar-un-Nisa etc., as such, this fact is sufficient to declare that the alleged allotment in favour of Akhtar-un-Nisa etc. was based on fraud, which is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
11. As regard the arguments of learned counsel for the petitioners that the matter is a past and closed transaction and Settlement authority is debarred to reopen the same, suffice it to say in this regard that as the record of the case shows the existence of a colourful exercise applied with inter se collusiveness of the parties to usurp the valuable evacuee / State property, as such, protection cannot be given to the petitioners under the past and closed transaction. Moreover, connivances of the parties with the adjudicator who does not enlarge his jurisdiction at his own whims and caprice and any such order passed by an interested authority is coram non-judice, void, tainted with grotesque motive which does not have any legal protection and will never be considered as past and closed transaction. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of Pakistan has elaborately discussed and answered the matter of past and closed transaction in a recent judgment reported as Shahid Pervaiz v. Ejaz Ahmad and others (2017 SCMR 206) declaring that the principle of past and closed transaction would apply in case where rights were created under the valid law, even if such law was subsequently lapsed or was removed from the statute book, be considered as protected under the doctrine of past and closed transaction. The Courts are duty bound to protect the rights and interests created under a law and deny to protect such rights obtained under an invalid law. Where a party claiming the protection of rights created under a law but failed to pass the test of constitutionality, as determined by the court, it could not take the plea of past and closed transaction. Reliance is also placed on Province of the Punjab through Member Judicial-V/Chief Settlement Commissioner, Punjab, Board of Revenue, Lahore v. Notified Officer, Lahore and others (2018 YLR 2073).
2751. Admittedly the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Act, 1958 was repealed through promulgation of and the Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act, 1975 whereafter no fresh allotment could be made by the Notified Officer/CSC and if any earlier allotment of evacuee land was obtained fraudulently he has the inbuilt inherent power to investigate the matter of fraudulent allotment of the evacuee land as the fraudulent allotment wears no sanctity in the eyes of law. The Chief Settlement Commissioner has a jurisdiction to adjudicate or investigate the genuineness of the evacuee's claim, and allotment made whereof if he found the existence of any fraud committed in obtaining the allotment of the evacuee property, he can reverse the said allotment order. The issue of jurisdiction of the Chief Settlement Commissioner/ Notified Officer has been settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of Pakistan in a recent judgment reported as Messrs Beach Luxury Hotels, Karachi v. Messrs Anas Muneer Ltd. and others (2016 SCMR 222) wherein it is observed that when a matter of allotment is re-opened, the Settlement Authority has the jurisdiction to re-examine all the facts pertaining to the title of the parties from the very inception of claim and to decide the matter according to available record as per law. In another judgment cited as Virasat Ullah Bashir Ahmad, Settlement Commissioner (Industries) and another (1969 SCMR 154), the Hon'ble Supreme Court of Pakistan has observed as under:--
2752. "We are unable to see any point in this leave petition except the uneasiness on the part of the petitioner to undo the notice issued to him by the Settlement Commissioner which merely required that the petitioner should disclose his credential as the transferee of the property in dispute. The learned Single Judge has directed that the entitlement of the petitioner should be duly examined and we see no apparent reason why the petitioner wants to avoid this examination. The grievance of the petitioner at this stage is baseless and premature. This petition is dismissed."
2753. (emphasis supplied)
2754. The above said view has been reiterated in case reported as Chief Settlement Commissioner, Lahore v. Raja Muhammad Fazil Khan and others (PLD 1975 SC 331). Moreover Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 confers an inherent jurisdiction to an authority which has passed the order that said authority has the jurisdiction to undo the erroneous or illegal order passed by it. Similarly if any benefit has been obtained from authority by practicing misrepresentation or fraud, the same forum is vested inbuilt jurisdiction to undo the same. In this regard the Hon'ble Supreme Court of Pakistan in a case titled as Muhammad Baran and others v. Member (Settlement and Rehabilitation) Board of Revenue Punjab and others (PLD 1991 SC 691) has held that where the allotment order made by the authorities was illegal, without jurisdiction, based on fraud and forgery, in that eventuality Chief Settlement Commissioner/ Notified Officer can interfere with illegal transfer of properties by its own motion against the exposed fraud or forgery and in such like matter, the superior Courts should avoid to exercise their discretionary writ jurisdiction to annul the such order, even though it was clearly without jurisdiction. Relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced as under:-
2755. "Putting this observation in juxtaposition to the present case; if the allotments relied upon by the appellants made by the Settlement functionaries were illegal and without jurisdiction and indeed if they were also based on fraud and forgery, in that eventuality even if the Board of Revenue which exposed fraud and forgery and set aside illegal transfer of properties worth millions by its own order, the High Court would not in exercise of its discretionary (Writ) jurisdiction annul the order of the Board of Revenue, even though, to borrow the language used in the case of Raunaq Ali the latter "was clearly without jurisdiction."
2756. Further in another judgment reported as Shamrooz Khan v. Muhabbat Khan and another (1989 SCMR 819), the Hon'ble Apex Court held that the Settlement Authorities have jurisdiction to issue notices on the complaint wherein it reveals that the order of transfer was procured on the basis of fraud and non-existent documents. The relevant portion of the judgment (supra) is reproduced as under:-
2757. "The jurisdiction of the Tribunal or the Deputy Settlement Commissioner in this case to examine the question of forgery and fabrication in his own record has been upheld by the learned Judge in the High Court and it follows from our decision in the Chief Settlement Commissioner, Lahore v. Raja Muhammad Fazil Khan and others (PLD 1975 SC 331). On no principle, known to the Constitutional jurisdiction, the power of the Tribunal to adjudicate a matter within its jurisdiction could be pre-empted by the High Court in the words in which it has been done. The Custodian of the record is the best judge in the first place to determine the veracity, the correctness and the genuineness of its own record. It should have been given an opportunity to discharge its duty in that respect. It is only then that a review of the adjudication could have taken place in the High Court.
2758. We accept the appeal, set aside the judgment of High Court, recall the writ and allow the Deputy Settlement Commissioner to proceed with the determination of the allegations made in the Application in accordance with the law applicable. No order as to costs."
12. This argument of learned counsel for the petitioner that as per a case cited as Javed Akhtar Khan v. DCO/District Collector, Sheikhupura (PLJ 2019 Lahore 647) once an order of allotment was given effect in the record of rights (Jamabandi), the non-attestation of mutation is inconsequential under Rule 7-A of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Rules, 1959. To answer this proposition, it is expedient to discuss the provisions Section 33, Section 34, Section 35 and Section 37 of the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 which deal with significance of Registration and attestation of mutation in the revenue record. The above said provisions are reproduced as under:
2759. "33. Annual record:--
(1) .. ..
(2) .
(3) For the purposes of the preparation of the annual record, the Collector shall cause to be kept up by the patwari of each estate a register of mutations and such other registers as the Financial Commissioner may prescribe.
34. Making of that part of the annual record which relates to land-owners, assignees of revenue and occupancy tenants: -
(1) Any person acquiring, by inheritance, purchase, mortgage, or otherwise, any right in an estate as a landowner, assignee of land-revenue or tenant having a right of occupancy, shall report his acquisition of the right to the patwari of the estate.
(2) If the person acquiring the right is a minor or otherwise disqualified, his guardian or other person having charge of his property shall make the report to the patwari.
(3) The patwari shall enter in his register of mutations every report made to him under sub-section (1) or subsection (2), and shall also make an entry therein respecting the acquisition of any such right as aforesaid which he has reason to believe to have taken place, and of which a report should have been made to him under one or other of those subsections and has not been so made.
(4) A Revenue Officer shall from time to time inquire into the correctness of all entries in the register of mutations and into all such acquisitions as aforesaid coming to his knowledge of which, under the foregoing sub-sections, report should have been made to the patwari and entry made in that register and shall in each case make such order as he thinks fit with respect to the entry in the annual record of the right acquired.
(5) Such an entry shall be made by the insertion in that record of description of the right acquired and by the omission from that record of any entry in any record previously prepared which by reason of the acquisition has ceased to be correct.
35. Making of that part of the annual record which relates to other persons:--The acquisition of any interest in land other than a right referred to in subsection (1) of the last foregoing section shall:-
(a) if it is undisputed, be recorded by the patwari in such manner as the Financial Commissioner may by rule in this behalf prescribe; and
(b) if it is disputed, be entered by the patwari in the register of mutations and dealt with in the manner prescribed in sub-sections (4) and (5) of the last foregoing section.
37. Restrictions on variations of entries in records:--Entries in record-of-rights or in annual records, except entries made in annual records by Patwaris under clause (a) of section 35 with respect to undisputed acquisitions of interest refered to in that section, shall not be varied in subsequent records otherwise than by-
(a) making entries in accordance with facts proved or admitted to have occurred;
(b) making such entries as are agreed to by all the parties interested therein or are supported by a decree or order binding on those parties;
(c) making new maps where it is necessary to make them.
2760. (emphasis supplied)
2761. Through the Punjab Land Revenue (West Pakistan Amendment) Ordinance, 1963 (Ordinance XVIII of 1963), section 37-A was added in the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 on which basis the provisions of subsection (3) of section 33, section 34, s ection 35 and section 37, reproduced above, were suspended and it was decided that in pursuance of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Act, 1958 all the entries required to be made in the record of rights directly without observing the procedure prescribed by subsection (3) of section 33, section 34, section 35 and section 37. For ready reference the relevant provision of the Ordinance ibid is reproduced as under:
2762. "Insertion of section 37-A in Act XVII of 1887. --- After section 37 of the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887, as applicable to the Divisions of Lahore, Rawalpindi, Sargodha, Multan, Bahawalpur, Peshawar, Dera Ismail Khan, Quetta and Kalat and the Nasirabad Sub-Division of Jacobabad District, the following new section shall be added, namely :-
2763. "37-A. Where any interest in evacuee land is acquired by the Central Government or the Provincial Government or where such interest is transferred by the Central Government or the Provincial Government to a claimant in pursuance of the provisions of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Act, 1958 (Act XLVII of 1958) and the rules made thereunder the provisions of subsection (3) of section 33, section 34, section 35 and section 37 shall be suspended and entries required to be made in the record-of-rights or annual record in pursuance of the said Act or the rules shall be made directly without observing the procedure prescribed by the sub-section (3) of section 33, section 34, section 35 and section 37. "
2764. Thereafter, vide notification No.S.R.O(R)/64 dated 24.12.1964, rule 7-A was added in the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement) Rules, 1959. For ready reference, rule 7-A is reproduced as under:
2765. "7-A. Mutation. (1) After the acquisition of the land under Section 4, the Revenue Officer of the area concerned shall cause a mutation of extinction of all evacuee rights and interests in the entire estate to be entered and disposed of and the Central Government shall be substituted for the evacuee holders of right in the estate.
(2) After the land has been finally allotted and settled as prescribed by the preceding rule, the Revenue Authority of the area concerned shall, for the purpose of making entries in respect of rights and interests of the allottees in the record of rights or register Haq Daran Zameen or in village form No.VII, as the case may be, treat the entries in R.L.II at par with those in a register of mutation and it shall not be necessary to sanction any mutation for the purpose."
2766. On 28.12.1967, the Province of West Pakistan through a notification No.599/67/319-U.(1) enforced the West Pakistan Land Revenue Act, 1967 w.e.f. 01.01.1968 and under Section 184 of the said Act, the Punjab Land Revenue (West Pakistan Amendment) Ordinance, 1963 was repealed. Thereafter on 16.05.1968, through a circular No.102, the Settlement Department issued instructions/directions to the allottees as well as to the revenue authorities to incorporate the mutations under the West Pakistan Land Revenue Act, 1967 regarding allotment of evacuee land made by the Settlement authorities. For ready reference, circular No.102 dated 06.05.1968 is reproduced as under:
(6) INCORPORATION OF ENTRIES OF REGISTER R.I., II, IN THE RECORDS-OF-RIGHTS AND PERIODICAL RECORDS (REGISTER HAQDARAN ZAMIN)
2767. (D.L.R.'s Circular Letter No. 102, dated 6.5.1968 addressed to all D.Cs. and Settlement Officers etc.)
2768. (emphasis supplied)
13. Section 39 of the West Pakistan Land Revenue Act, 1967 elucidates the vitality of record of right and Periodical Record which are meant to demonstrate the statements showing, the persons who are land-owners, tenants or recipient any of the rents, profits or produce of the estate or to occupy land therein; the nature and extent of the interest of those person, and the conditions and liabilities attaching thereto; and the rent, land-revenue, rates, cesses or other payments, due from each person. Under Clauses 7.1 (a), 7.2 of Land Record Manual (Chapter 7) Part-A, the entry of mutation is prescribed which is reproduced as under:-
2769. "7.
1. Entry of Mutation: The mutation register is prescribed in [sections 33 (3) and 34 of the Land Revenue Act] for the entry of [every acquisition of any right or interest in an estate as a landowner, assignee or occupancy tenant], and under [section 35] for disputed acquisition of other rights. The mutation register is not a part of the record-of-rights and its entries do not share in the presumption of truth attached to that record. All mutations of rights of ownership including voluntary partitions, shall be entered by the patwari in the register when they are reported to him by the transferee as required by [section 34 of the Land Revenue Act], and if not so reported, then as soon as they appear to have been acted upon. When he enters a mutation affecting the shajra nasb the patwari shall not in pencil the number of the mutation against the entry affected. If and when the mutation is sanctioned he shall amend the shajra nasb in red ink in accordance with the mutation order. To effect the prompt entry of mutations the following procedure shall be followed:--
(i) On an oral or application in writing, made to the Patwari by either of the parties concerned, necessary entries in the remarks column of the mutation sheet shall be made immediately.
(ii) As laid down in the standing instructions, in para 3.81 the factum of receipt of such a report or application shall also be recorded in the
(iii) In no case shall the completion of the entries in the mutation sheet remain pending with the Patwari for more than 15 days without obtaining prior approval of the circle revenue officer. The reasons for the delay, if any, shall be recorded in the remarks column.
(iv) Presence of parties is not necessary for entering a mutation; hence their absence or the Patwari's preoccupation with other work shall not be accepted as pretext for delayed entry of mutations beyond 15 days of the original report. Action shall invariably be initiated by the halqa revenue officer whenever a case of delayed entry is detected. In case he fails to do so action shall be taken against the halqa officer himself.
(v) It shall not be difficult for a Patwari (resident official) to learn in normal course of the occurrence of death of landowner in his small circle. Mutations of inheritance in such case can, therefore, be entered by the Patwari suo motu on the basis of his personal knowledge without waiting for any formal intimation from any quarter. In further failure to enter a mutation of inheritance on the death of a resident land-owner shall be construed to reflect adversely on the vigilance and awareness of Patwari and shall be taken due notice of.
(vi) It shall be the duty of the Patwari to bring the fact of having entered a mutation to the notice of the halqa officer during the Patwari's next visit to the Tehsil headquarters if the officer has not toured his circle earlier and noted on every pending mutation. The halqa officer shall initial all mutations entered by the Patwari or Tapedar since his last visit and shall note the fact for planning his subsequent tour programme.]
2770. [7.1-A. Report under section 42 regarding acquisition of rights to the Assistant Commissioner or Chairman of the Union Council. - In addition to the procedure referred to in para 7.1 any interested person may report regarding acquisition of right orally or in writing to the -
(a) Assistant Commissioner concerned on the first 4 working days of every month when the Patwari attend the Tehsil Officer; and
(b) Chairman/Vice-Chairman of the Union Council concerned on every Sunday when Patwari attend the office of the Union Council under paragraph 3.17(2). The Assistant Commissioner or the Chairman/Vice-Chairman as the case may be, shall thereupon cause such report to be entered by the Patwari in the Roznamcha Waqiati and in the register of mutation.]
2771. 7.2. Reference in jamabandi (Register Haqdaran Zamin) : The patwari should, whenever a mutation case is entered in the register, not the serial number and nature of the transfer in pencil in the column of remarks of the [jamabandi] opposite the appropriate holding. If and when the mutation is sanctioned, he should make the above note in red ink. Serial numbers of fard badar entries should also be similarly noted and in order to distinguish them from the serial number of mutations the word "badar" should be added. Fard badar entries will thus be referred to as (1) badar, (2) badar, etc., etc."
2772. Section 42 of the West Pakistan Land Revenue Act, 1967 deals with the procedure in respect of making of that part of periodical records which relates to landowners. For ready reference, section 42 is reproduced as under:-
2773. "42. Making of that part of periodical records which relates to land-owners.---(1) Any person acquiring by inheritance, purchase, mortgage, gift, or otherwise, any right in an estate as a land-owner, or a tenant for a fixed term exceeding one year, shall, within three months from the date of such acquisition, report his acquisition of right to the Patwari of the estate, who shall-
(a) record such report in the Roznamacha to be maintained in the prescribed manner;
(b) furnish a copy of the report so recorded, free of cost, to the person making the report; and
(c) send a copy of the report, within a week of its receipt by him, to the Union Committee, Town Committee or Union Council within which the estate is situated.
2774. Note: In the Province of Punjab the words "Union Committee, Town Committee or Union Council" have been substituted by the words "Office of the Union Administration" by Punjab Ordinance LV of 2001, PLD 2002 Pun.St.154.
(2) If the person acquiring the right is a minor or is otherwise unable to report, his guardian or other person having charge of his property shall make the report to the Patwari.
(3) The Patwari shall enter in his register of mutations ever report made to him under subsection (1) or subsection (2), and shall also make an entry in the Roznamcha and in the register of mutations respecting the acquisition of any such right as aforesaid which he has reason to believe to have taken place, and of which report should have been made to him under either of those subsections and has not been so made.
(4) The report made to the Patwari under subsection (1) or subsection (2) or recorded by him under subsection (3) shall be displayed in such manner as may be prescribed.
(5) If the Patwari fails to record or to display a report made to him under subsection (1) or sub-section (2), the person making the report may make the report, in writing, to the Revenue Officer concerned and the [Chairman of the Union Committee, Town Committee or Union Council] in which the estate is situated, by registered post acknowledgement due and the Revenue Officer shall thereupon cause such report to be entered in the register of mutations.
(6) A Revenue Officer shall, from time to time, inquire into the correctness of all entries in the register of mutations and into all such acquisitions as aforesaid coming to his knowledge of which, under the foregoing sub-sections, report should have been made to the Patwari and entries made in that register, and, shall in each case make such order as he thinks fit with respect to any entry in the periodical record of the right acquired.
(7) Except in cases of inheritance or where the acquisition of the right is by a registered deed or by or under an order or decree of a Court, the Revenue Officer shall make the order under sub-section (6) in the presence of the person whose right has been acquired, after such person has been identified by two respectable persons, preferably from Lambardars or members of the "Zila Council, Tehsil Council or Town Council" or Union Council concerned, whose signatures or thumb-impressions shall be obtained by the Revenue Officer on the register of mutations.
(8) An inquiry or an order under subsection (6) shall be made in the common assembly in the estate to which the mutation, which is the subject matter of the inquiry, relates.
(9) Where a Revenue Officer makes an order under sub-section (6) in regard to the acquisition of any right, an entry shall be made in the periodical record by the insertion therein of a description of the right acquired and by the omission from such record of any entry in any record previously prepared, which, by reason of the acquisition, has ceased to be correct.
(10) If within three months of the making of a report of the acquisition of a right under sub-section (1) or subsection (2), or the recording by the Patwari of an entry in the Roznamcha under subsection (3) respecting the acquisition of any right, no order is made by the Revenue Officer under subsection (6), he shall report the cause of delay to the Collector in the prescribed manner.
(11) The Revenue Officer shall, in the prescribed manner, send or cause to be sent, the gist of an order made by him under sub-section (6), to the person whose right is acquired, and also to the office of the Union Administration in which the estate is situated."
2775. From the perusal of the aforesaid provisions it is very much clear that any person acquiring any right as a purchaser, inheritor, donee, mortgagee or otherwise in any estate, the Patwari shall record such report in Roznamcha to be maintained in the prescribed manner furnished copy of report within a week to concerned Town Committee or Union Council and subsection (3) of section 42, the Patwari shall enter in his register of mutations every report made to him under subsection (1) or subsection (2) of section 42 and shall also make an entry in the Roznamcha and in the register of mutations regarding the acquisition of any such right as aforesaid which he has reason to believe to have taken place, and of which report should have been made to him under either of those subsections and has not been so made.
2776. Under Section 184 of the West Pakistan Land Revenue Act, 1967, all the revenue laws mentioned in Schedule Parts I and II, including the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887 as well as the Punjab Land Revenue (West Pakistan Amendment) Ordinance, 1963, were repealed and a complete procedure is given in Sections 39 to 48 of Chapter V of the West Pakistan Land Revenue Act, 1967 for the incorporation of the Record of Rights and documents required therein and it is settled law that statutory law on the subject shall prevail over the rules guidelines, instructions etc. Reliance is placed on Province of the Punjab, through Secretary, Livestock and Dairy Development Department, Punjab, Lahore and others v. Syed Munir Hussain Shah [1998 PLC (C.S.) 868] and Additional Collector, Sales Tax, Lahore and another v. Rupafab Limited and others (2001 PTD 2383).
2777. Moreover the Chief Settlement Commissioner vide notification No.1624/ 78/855/RL dated 19th June, 1978 decided that any allotment which has not yet been incorporated in the revenue record before coming into force of the Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act, 1975 or within one year after passing of allotment order, whichever is later, may be deemed to have been obtained fraudulently by ante-dating the entries in the register R.L.II and should be considered as cancelled forthwith, after hearing objections, if any, of the so-called allottee. For ready reference, aforesaid notification is reproduced as under:-
2778. No.1624/78/855/RL
2779. Office of the Member Board of Revenue
2780. (Settlement and Rehabilitation Wing)
2781. Punjab.
2782. Dated Lahore the 19.6.1978.
2783. From
2784. Mian Waheed-ud-Din Rathoro,
2785. Secretary (Rural)
2786. (Settlement and Rehab. Wing)
2787. Board of Revenue Punjab.
2788. To
1. All the wholetime Settlement Commissioners (L) and Addl: Settlement Commissioners (L) Punjab.
2. All the Deputy Commissioners and Assistant Commissioners (ASC) (L) in the Punjab.
2789. Subject: Allotment of resumed land to informers etc. Mr. A.K.Khalid, C.S.C./Member Board of Revenue (S&R) Punjab.
2790. MEMORANDUM:
2791. The Chief Settlement Commis- sioner/Member, Board of Revenue (S&R) Punjab, has been pleased to decide that any allotment that has not been incorporated in the revenue record before coming into force of the Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons (Repeal) Act, 1975 or within one year of the passing of allotment order, whichever is later, may be deemed to have been obtained fraudulently by ante-dating the entries in the register R.L.II and should be cancelled forthwith, after hearing objections, if any, of the so-called allottee.
2. The Chief Settlement Commissioner/Member Board of Revenue (S&R) Punjab, has further been pleased to order that all cases where land has been resumed on 'Mukhbari' applications filed by attorneys of the original claimants should invariably be submitted to the Chief Settlement Commissioner for necessary orders as he thinks necessary with regard to the proposal/allotment of the land so resumed, under Section 14 (1A) of the Displaced Persons (Land Settlement Act, 1958, read with section 3 of the Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act, 1975.
3. You are, therefore, requested kindly to ensure strict compliance of orders of Chief Settlement Commissioner/ Member Board of Revenue accordingly, without further delay.
2792. Sd/-SECRETARY RURAL)
2793. (SETT: & REHAB. WING)
2794. BOARD OF REVENUE PUNJAB.
2795. No.1624/78/855/RL dated 19th June, 1978.
2796. A copy is forwarded to all the Commissioners/Addl. Commissioners (Settlement Commissioners (Land) Punjab for information and necessary action.
2797. Sd/-SECRETARY RURAL)
2798. (SETT: & REHAB. WING)
2799. BOARD OF REVENUE PUNJAB.
2800. Despite the above unambiguous instructive or the restrictive order of the competent authority, the subordinate revenue officials keep on incorporating the allotment order in the revenue record which necessitated the reiteration and recirculation of above notification. The successor Chief Settlement Commissioner vide notification dated 7th December 2000 again directed the subordinate revenue authorities to stop the further implementation of bogus allotments in revenue record in terms of notification dated 5th September, 1979. For ready reference, notification whereof is reproduced as under:-
2801. No.2127-2000/3321/PA/Secy (S&R),
2802. Board of Revenue, Punjab,
2803. Farid Kot House, Lahore,
2804. Dated the 7th Dec: 2000
2805. From
2806. The Board of Revenue, Punjab.
2807. To
1. All Commissioners in the Province.
2. All Deputy Commissioners in the Province.
2808. Subject: ORDER OF SENIOR MEMBER, BOARD OF REVENUE / MEMBER JUDICIAL-I, IN ROR NO.2469/ 95, SHAUKAT ALI ETC VERSUS PROVINCE OF PUNJAB DATED 18-07-2000.
2809. It is a matter of common knowledge that various persons from all walks of life, either sitting behind the scene or in the open are out to grab valuable evacuee property through fraud, forgery or manipulation.
2810. Two cases were recently detected in which allotment orders were fabricated and bogus verification was made. The Deputy Commissioner, Gujranwala has been directed to get the criminal cases registered against the culprits.
2811. The case mentioned at subject noted above was decided by the Senior Member/Member-Judl.1, dated 18-7-2000 copy of which is enclosed. The revenue authorities implemented bogus allotment in Register RL-II dated 1971 in revenue record in year 1995. Whereas instructions issued by the Settlement and Rehabilitation Wing of Board of Revenue, Punjab, Notification No. 1624/ 78/854, dated 19-06-1978 are as under:-
2812. "The Chief Settlement Commis- sioner/Member, Board of Revenue (S& R) Punjab, has been pleased to decide that any allotment that has not been incorporated in the revenue record before coming into force of the Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons (Repeal) Act, 1975 or within one year of the passing of allotment order, whichever is later, may be deemed to have been obtained fraudulently by anti-dating the entries in the register R.L.II and should be cancelled forthwith, after hearing objections, if any, of the so-called allottee".
2813. In view of the situation explained above, the Chief Settlement Commissioner, Punjab/Member, Board of Revenue, has been pleased to direct as follows:-
1. No mutation transferring proprietary rights of the land allotted by any order should be sanctioned without prior approval of the Chief Settlement Commissioner, Punjab verbally as well as in writing by an officer not less than a Deputy Commissioner of the District personally to avoid further fraud.
2. A fraud is always a fraud and it is well settled law that nobody can be allowed to reap the Fruit of fraud and retain ill -gotten gains. In order to achieve this objective all allotments made after repeal of Settlements Laws in year 1975 will have to be reviewed and as a start the Deputy Commissioners are requested to send all allotment orders received in their districts after 1990 to the Board of Revenue, Punjab for re-verification.
3. Notification dated 5th September, 1979 lays down that allotments obtained on the basis of forged or fabricated orders are total nullity in the eyes of law and, therefore, should be ignored as non-existent and the land treated as still available for disposal. The Deputy Commissioner are directed to trace out such allotments and take necessary action in the light of these instructions.
2814. MEMBER, BOARD OF REVENUE/
2815. CHIEF SETTLEMENT COMMISSIONER,
2816. PUNJAB, LAHORE
2817. NO. AND DATE EVEN
2818. A copy is forwarded for information to:-
1. The Chief Secretary, Government of the Punjab, Lahore
2. The Senior Member, Board of Revenue, Punjab.
2819. MEMBER, BOARD OF REVENUE/
2820. CHIEF SETTLEMENT COMMISSIONER,
2821. PUNJAB, LAHORE
2822. From perusal of the above mentioned provision of Land Revenue Act, policy guidelines as well as the notification dated 19.06.1978, issued by the Chief Settlement Commissioner any allotment which has not yet been incorporated in the revenue record before coming into force of the Evacuee Property and Displaced Persons Laws (Repeal) Act, 1975 or within one year after passing of allotment order, whichever is later, may be deemed to have been obtained fraudulently by ante-dating the entries in the register R.L.II and should be considered as cancelled forthwith, after hearing objections, if any, of the so-called al lottee. From the perusal of the aforesaid notifications, it was mandatory for an allottee to get incorporate the allotment in the revenue record within the prescribed period and non-compliance of the above provisions and policy decision badly frustrate the validity and veracity of the alleged allotment.
2823. While in the cited judgment Javed Akhtar Khan v. DCO/District Collector, Sheikhupura (PLJ 2019 Lahore 647) the aforementioned provisions of law, facts, amendments, circular No.102 and notification dated 14.06.1978 were neither presented before the Hon'ble Court nor properly argued for which reason the facts mentioned in preceding paragraphs of this Court's judgment have not been considered and discussed in the supra pronouncement, as such, the case law relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners is not helpful for his case here and the sanction of mutation in the revenue record regarding the allotment of evacuee under a valid transaction is necessary to avoid or eliminate the further mischief and to confer a complete authenticity to the title of a party. As discussed above the evacuee land in Mouza Amar Sadhu was precluded from Rehabilitation process and was not part of the compensation pool and same could not be allotted against any evacuee claim in existence of Notification of 1966 as well as 1973 and any allotment obtained in violation of the above policy notification, such allotment has no legal worth and value, as such the allotments of Zaheer Siddique and Syeda Akhtar un Nisa have rightly been cancelled by the Chief Settlement Commissioner through the impugned order and W. P.No.76-R of 2010 deserves dismissal.
15. Now coming to the matter of subsequent al ienee from the allottees M.Zaheer Siddiqui subject matter of W.P.No.96-R of 2010. Admittedly Sh. Rauf Ahmad claimed to be the donee of the disputed land from Zaheer Ahmad Siddique who issued a document of power of attorney in favour of Sh. Farooq Ahmad the real brother of the petitioner and it was the said attorney (Sh. Farooq Ahmad) who gifted out the said land to his real brother (the petitioner) through gift mutation No.39149 dated 06.01.2003, whereas under the law the attorney is denuded of any authority to make gift on behalf of the principal rather it is personal act of the principal to pronounce gift and attorney can only finalize the subsequent stipulation of gift already made by the principal. Moreover, admittedly donee is brother of the attorney who cannot make any alienation to his close relative without obtaining prior special permission from the principal, as such, the petitioner has no locus standi to challenge the impugned order. Reliance is placed on Reliance is placed on the cases of Fida Muhammad v. Pir Muhammad Khan (deceased) through LRs and others (PLD 1985 SC 341) and Mst.Naila Kausar and another v. Sardar Muhammad Bakhsh (2016 SCMR 1781).
2824. The learned counsel for the petitioner (in W.P.No.96- R/2010) argued that the Chief Minister Punjab after holding an inquiry regarding the claim of the petitioner, ordered to restore the mutation in favour of the petitioner and the Settlement authority lack jurisdiction to undo the order of higher authorities, suffice it to say that the Chief Minister has no authority in law to allot or give the State land to any person. Reliance can also be placed on the case titled as American International School System v. Mian Muhammad Ramzan and others (2015 SCMR 1449), wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of Pakistan held as under:-
2825. "21. As discussed above, the petitioner-School was not eligible to be allotted evacuee land under the Scheme, 1977. There is nothing on record to substantiate the claim of the petitioner-School that it was allotted subject land in the public interest. The Chief Minister does not possess any plenary authority and or jurisdiction to allot any land as a matter of grace or favour at his whims and fancy, but in accordance with law. The public functionaries are the custodians of the public/State land, which could only be disposed of in accordance with law. "
16. Now attending to the issue of subsequent alienee, D.H.A. (petitioner in W.P. No. 172-R/201 0), who claims to be a purchaser of the land from Mst. Akhtar un Nisar claimant/allottee, suffice it to say that admittedly they derived alleged right from their vendors and subsequent alienee who stepped into shoes of their vendor are debarred to claim any better title and subsequent alienees have no protection under Section 41 of Transfer of Property Act and if any infirmity, deficiency or flaw subsequently emerges in the title of owner that shall always travel with the land and transferee is precluded to raise plea of protection under Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act. Reliance can be placed on the case titled as Muhammad Yamin and others v. Settlement Commissioner and others 1976 SCMR 489). Further reliance is placed on the case as Bashir Ahmad and others v. Additional Commissioner with powers of Settlement Commissioner (L) and others (1983 SCMR 1199) held as under:-
2826. "...Since, an allotment of land is subject to the provision of sections 10 and 11, every purchaser from a allottee is to be saddled with the knowledge that the transaction of purchase is subject to the incidence of those sections and as such he cannot raise the plea of protection on the principle of section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act. His remedy is not against the Department but against the vendor. We are, therefore, inclined to hold that the view taken in the earlier two cited cases will govern the contention raised before us. "
2827. In another case titled Talib Hussain and others v. Member, Board of Revenue and others (2003 SCMR 549), the Hon'ble Apex Court held as under:-
2828. "It is important to emphasis that petitioner's entitlement is based upon the entitlement of Syed Nizamuddin, therefore, petitioner either to have survive or sink depending upon determination of legal status of the property which was transferred to him and as now he has failed to keep his entitlement alive, therefore, petitioner's claim is bound to be rejected."
2829. In a case titled Abdul Hamid v. M.B.R. and others (1994 CLC 1160), this Court held as under:-
2830. "4. The learned counsel for the petitioners has contended that all the petitioners are bona fide purchasers for value of the land from the transferee and they are entitled to retain the same. It is not disputed that transfer in favour of Noor Muhammad was found to be fraudulent. Not only that it was further found by the Notified Officer that Noor Muhammad, the real claimant, A was not traceable and some other person had obtained allotment by impersonating him. As the vendor of the petitioners had no right in the land, he could not pass any title to the petitioners and they have no consequently legal right to retain the land (See Gul Muhammad and others v. The Additional Settlement Commissioner and others (1985 SCMR 491) and Manzoor Hussain v. Fazal Hussain and others (1984 SCMR 1027). "
2831. In a case titled as Mst. Aziz Bibi and 22 others v. Additional Commissioner (Revenue) with the Powers of Settlement Commissioner (Lands), Lahore Division and another (2002 YLR 3268) this Court has observed that "since an allotment of land is subject to the provision or sections 10 and 11, every transferee from an allottee is to be saddled with the knowledge that the transaction of purchase is subject to the incidence of those sections and as such he cannot raise the plea of protection on the principle of bona fide transferee as envisaged in section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act. In another case titled as Rasheed Ahmad and 2 others v. Additional Commissioner (Rev.) Notified Officer Gujranwala Division, Gujranwala and others (2007 CLC 1801) the learned Division Bench of this Court held as under:-
2832. "8. Abdul Baqi is the original allottee. His claim was found bogus. Sale in favour of respon-dents will not confer better title to them. They will sink or swim with him and thus, are not protected under section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act. We respectfully follow the above view.
2833. As the alleged allotments in favour of Muhammad Zaheer Siddiqui and Mst. Akhtar-un-Nisa etc. have been declared as bogus, as such, the subsequent alienees have to sail and sink with their transferer and they are debarred to claim any better title.
2834. The Chief Settlement Commis-sioner/Notified Officer, after minutely perusing the record and hearing the parties, rightly passed the impugned order which does not require any interference. Learned counsel for the petitioners has failed to point out any perversity, illegality or any jurisdictional defect in the impugned order calling for any interference by this Court in its constitutional jurisdiction.
17. So far as the writ petition of Syed Moiz Ahmad and others who claim to be the progeny of the predeceased son of Syed Aziz Ahmad the displaced person and assert their entitlement in the allotted land in favour of Akhtar un Nisar etc. suffice it to say that the allotment of their grand-mother Syeda Akhtar un Nisa has been declared as illegal, as such their claim stood automatically extinguished and the W.P. No.136-R of 2010 has gone infructuous.
18. In view of above, this writ petition as well as all the connected writ petitions are hereby dismissed being devoid of any merits.
2835. MH/R-1/L Petitions dismissed.