Pakistan Case Law
1984 SCMR 177

Qazi SARDAR BAHADAR vs SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HEALTH, ISLAMABAD AND OTHERS

⭐ Prefer in Google
Citation1984 SCMR 177
CourtSupreme Court of Pakistan
Case No.Civil Petition No, 515-R of 1983
Date1983-11-21
Judge(s)Muhammad Haleem, Actg. C. J., Aslam Riaz Hussain, Muhammad Afzal Zullah and M. S. H. Quraishi
Authored byM. S. H. Quraishi
ResultPetition dismissed
AI Summary — generated from this judgment; read the full text below and verify before relying on it.

The petitioner, an Upper Division Clerk, challenged the termination of his services after overstaying his ex-Pakistan leave. Having gone abroad in June 1978, the petitioner sought multiple extensions, eventually requesting a five-year extension in March 1980. However, his services had already been terminated effective December 1979. Upon receiving notice of termination in April 1980, the petitioner did not seek reinstatement until November 1982. His subsequent departmental appeal was rejected as time-barred, a decision upheld by the Federal Service Tribunal on May 22, 1983. The Supreme Court of Pakistan reviewed the matter, considering the significant delay in challenging the termination. The Court held that there were no sufficient grounds to interfere with the Tribunal's decision, as the departmental appeal was hopelessly time-barred. Consequently, the petition for leave to appeal was refused, reinforcing the principle that administrative remedies must be pursued within the prescribed statutory limitation periods and that unexplained, substantial delays in challenging termination orders preclude judicial intervention.

Questions settled in this judgment
  • Can a service appeal be entertained when the departmental appeal is hopelessly time-barred?
  • Does the failure to challenge a termination order within the prescribed limitation period preclude judicial relief?
service mattertermination of servicelimitation periodtime-barred appealex-Pakistan leavedepartmental appealreinstatement

ORDER

' M. S. H. QURAISHI, J.-The petitioner, an Upper Division Clerk in the Central Government Hospital, Rawalpindi, went abroad on 7th June, 1978 on four months' ex-Pakistan leave. According to him, the leave had been extended by another four months and then for six months. He applied for further extension of the leave for a period of five years in March, 1980 but in the meantime his services had been terminated with effect from 12- 12-1979, the intimation of which was received by him while still abroad on 17-4-1980. He applied for reinstatement on 18-11-1982 but the same was rejected on 6-3- 983, against which he preferred an appeal before the Federal Service Tribunal. The Tribunal declined to interfere as in its view the appeal filed by the petitioner in the Department had been hopelessly time-barred and had been rightly dismissed. The Tribunal, therefore, dismissed the petitioner's appeal by the impugned order dated 22-5-1983.

2. We have heard the petitioner in person but we find no good ground to interfere. Leave to appeal is, therefore, refused. ,

Cited by 13 cases

For educational and research use only — not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.