SAEED AHMED vs THE STATE
This matter arises from a petition for leave to appeal against the dismissal of the petitioner's pre-trial or post-arrest bail application by the High Court. The petitioner, a retired Cashier of the Police Department, was accused in an F.I.R. registered under sections 406, 420, 468, and 471 of the Pakistan Penal Code (P.P.C.), with section 409 P.P.C. subsequently added, for allegedly failing to remit deductions to the District Police Welfare Punjab. The core legal question concerned the propriety of withholding bail where the case rests entirely on documentary evidence already in possession of the prosecution and challan has been submitted. The Supreme Court of Pakistan converted the petition into an appeal and allowed it, granting bail to the petitioner. The key principle laid down is that where a criminal case relies entirely on documentary evidence already secured and held by the prosecution, and challan has been submitted, the absence of any risk of tampering with evidence weighs heavily in favour of granting bail, notwithstanding the inclusion of offences falling within the prohibitory clause of section 497 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
- Whether bail should be granted when the case depends entirely on documentary evidence already in the possession of the prosecution?
- Does the absence of any possibility of tampering with evidence justify granting bail despite the addition of an offence falling within the prohibitory clause of section 497 Cr.P.C.?
- Whether the submission of challan and custody of documents with the prosecution are grounds for releasing an accused on bail?
- Section 406 P.P.C.
- Section 420 P.P.C.
- Section 468 P.P.C.
- Section 471 P.P.C.
- Section 409 P.P.C.
- Section 497 Cr.P.C.
ORDER
' SALEEM AKHTAR, J.---The petitioner seeks 10.Ave to appeal against the order of the learned Judge in Chambers whereby his bail application was dismissed.
2. The petitioner is a retired Cashier of the Police Department, who was In charge, Fund Section of S.S.P. Office, Lahore. He retired on 1-1-1991. On scrutiny of record it was found that he had not remitted 10% of the amount deducted from the reward paid to the police personnel to District Police Welfare Punjab. F.I.R. Was lodged on 27-12-1993 under sections 406; 420, 468 and 471, P.P.C. It was alleged that on scrutiny it was found that an amount of Rs,9,22,167.30 had not been deposited during the financial years 1987, 1988 and 1989: He was arrested on 8-1-1994 and challaned was submitted on 19-3-1994.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that there is no prohibition for grant of bail in respect of offences mentioned above, but with mala fide intention subsequently offence under section 409, P.P.C. Has also been added in order to bring the petitioner's case within the prohibitory clause of section 497; Cr.P.C. The case entirely depends upon documentary evidence which seems to be in possession of the prosecution and challan has already been submitted. The objection of the learned counsel regarding addition of section 409, P.P.C. May carry some weight while considering the bail application. As there is no possibility of tampering with the evidence, which is entirely documentary in nature and in possession of the prosecution, in the circumstances, we convert the petition into an appeal and allow it, and grant bail to the petitioner on furnishing one surety in the sum of Rs,50,000 to the satisfaction of the Deputy Registrar, Supreme Court, Lahore.
Cited by 80 cases
- Muhammad Irfan Versus State Fayyaz Ahmed Mehr 2026 YLR 2196
- Brigadier (Retired) Qaisar Shahzad vs The State, etc 2024 LHC 4459, 2025 MLD 122, PLJ 2025 Cr.C. 93
- Brigadier (Retired) Qaisar Shahzad Versus State 2025 MLD 122
- Fawad Ahmed vs National Accountability Bureau and 02 others. 2024 IHC 50, 2024 MLD 1207
- Imran Ahmed Khan Niazi vs The State, etc. 2023 IHC 150
- Imran Ahmed Khan Niazi, Imran Ahmed Khan Niazi vs The State, etc, Federation of Pakistan, etc 2023 IHC 112, PLJ 2024 Cr.C. 230, 2024 PLD Islamabad 87
- Mairajuddin vs The State 2023 PCRLJ 282
- Faisal Malhi Versus State 2025 YLR 2393
- Bilal Ahmed vs State and another PLJ 2022 Cr.C. 469
- Hussain Lawai vs The State and 2 others 2022 MLD 405
- Taha Raza and others vs The State and others 2022 PCRLJ 838
- Muhammad Ali Junejo vs The State 2022 MLD 58
- Masood Jillani etc vs State and another 2022 P Cr.L J 26, PLJ 2021 Cr.C. 1737
- Khizar Hayat vs The State and others 2021 MLD 1597
- Zulfiqar Ali vs State and another PLJ 2021 Cr.C. (Lahore) 357
- AZIZ ABDUL RAHIM KASSAM ALI Versus State 2021 YLRN 81
- SHOUKAT HUSSAIN JOKHIO Versus State 2021 PCrLJ 24
- Abdul Latif vs State etc PLJ 2020 Cr.C. (Lahore) 1439
- Mrs. ADEEBA KHAN Versus State 2021 PCrLJ 1577
- Abid Hussain vs State and another PLJ 2021 Cr.C. 1646
- Muhammad Bilal Sheikh vs National Accountability Bureau through Chairman and another 2020 P Cr. L J 671
- Muhammad Bilal Sheikh vs National Accountability Bureau through its 2020 IHC 6
- Faiz Rasool vs The State and others 2020 P Cr. L J 1598
- Sheikh Imran Haque vs Federation Of Pakistan through Secretary, Ministry 2020 PLD Islamabad 177
- ISMAIL WALIULLAH Versus State 2020 MLD 788
- Syed ZULQARNAIN SHAH Versus State 2022 PCrLJN 112
- MUHAMMAD SHABBIR Versus State 2020 YLRN 22
- INAMULLAH BHATTI Versus State 2019 YLRN 111
- MUHAMMAD BASHIR AHMAD vs STATE, etc PLJ 2019 Cr.C. 1392
- Manzoor Ahmad vs National Accountability Bureau (NAB) through Chairman, Islamabad and 2 others 2021 PLJ Lahore 112
- Abdul Rehman vs State etc. PLJ 2020 Cr.C. (Lahore) 404
- MUHAMMAD TARIQ vs The STATE and another 2019 P Cr. L J 872
- NADEEM ASLAM vs The STATE and another 2019 YLR 415
- NOMAN ALI BHATTI vs NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU and others 2019 PLJ Karachi 106, 2019 YLR 668
- SHARJEEL INAM MEMON and others vs NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU 2019 YLR 1426
- MUHAMMAD ASHRAF vs STATE and another PLJ 2019 Cr.C. 238
- SHABI HASSAN Versus State 2018 YLRN 69
- IMRAN GICHKI vs CHAIRMAN, NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU through Director-General and another 2017 PLJ Quetta 66, 2017 PLD Balochistan 89
- ABDUL HAMEED Versus State 2018 YLRN 75
- ABDUL WASAY SOOMRO Versus State 2017 YLRN 446
- ALI AHMED LUND vs The STATE through Chairman National Accountability 2018 YLR 491
- HASSAN SAMEER Versus State 2018 YLRN 52
- MUHAMMAD IQBAL vs STATE etc. 2018 PLJ Islamabad 17, 2018 KLR Criminal Cases 18
- Muhammad lqbal vs The State, etc. 2018 KLR Criminal Cases 18
- MUHAMMAD IQBAL Versus State 2017 PCrLJ 674
- ALI DINO GAHOTI Versus DIRECTOR GENERAL NAB 2017 PCrLJN 138
- ALI DINO GAHOTI Versus DIRECTOR-GENERAL NAB 2017 PCrLJN 193
- IMDAD HUSSAIN Versus State 2017 PCrLJN 13
- MUHAMMAD FARID ALAM Versus State 2017 PCrLJN 43
- SIKANDER ALI QURESHI vs CHAIRMAN, NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU 2017 P Cr. L J 269
…and 30 more citing cases