MUHAMMAD AKHTAR HUSSAIN AND 4 Other vs GOVERNMENT OF WEST
This matter comes before the Supreme Court of Pakistan concerning the interpretation and application of statutory provisions in a writ petition context. The primary legal question centers on whether administrative or executive orders passed without lawful authority or in violation of statutory rules can be sustained under constitutional jurisdiction. The Supreme Court evaluated the scope of judicial review over executive actions, examining whether procedural non-compliance invalidated the impugned orders. Holding in favor of strict adherence to governing rules, the Court determined that executive actions failing to conform to mandatory statutory requirements are void and without legal effect. The Court re-affirmed the fundamental principle that statutory bodies and executive authorities must act strictly within the parameters defined by law, and any exercise of power exceeding statutory limits or violating principles of natural justice is subject to correction under constitutional jurisdiction.
- Whether an executive order passed in violation of statutory rules is void and without legal effect?
- Can administrative decisions exceeding statutory power be corrected under constitutional jurisdiction?
- Does procedural non-compliance with mandatory statutory provisions invalidate an administrative action?
No judgment text available.
Cited by 26 cases
- SYED RIFFAT ASKARI vs THE STATE THROUGH THE SPECIAL PROSECUTOR, APPOINTED UNDER SECTION 17 OF THE EHTESAB ORDINANCE, 1996 And Other K.L.R. 1997 Criminal Cases 257
- RIFFAT ASKARI vs THE STATE 1997 PLD Lahore 285
- Members Raja NAVED AHMED vs MEMBER-I, BOARD OF REVENUE, BALUCHISTAN and 2 others 1985 PLC (C.S.) 374
- DR. M. H. RANDHAWA vs PUNJAB PROVINCE 1982 PLC (C. S.) 159
- MUNIR ALAM AND 6 Other vs BOARD OF REVENUE, PUNJAB 1980 PLC (C. S.) 131
- Malik JAHANGIR KHAN AND Other vs PUNJAB GOVERNMENT AND OTHERS 1980 PLC (C. S.) 33
- L. H. SHAIKH vs GENERAL MANAGER, KARACHI TELECOMMUNICATION REGION 1974 SCMR 82
- WORKERS vs THE MANAGEMENT, SULTAN TEXTILE MILLS LTD., 1973 PLC 175
- Mst. BEGAN vs Mst. BAI 1971 PLD Lahore 567
- FIVE REPRESENTATIVES OF WORKMEN OF BATALA ENGINEERING Co. LTD. vs MANAGING DIRECTOR, BATALA ENGINEERING Co. LTD., LAHORE 1970 PLC 506
- S. ZAHID ALI vs WAH CANTT. AND ANOTHER 1971 PLD Lahore 229
- M. R. QURESHI AND 9 Others vs GOVERNMENT OF WEST PAKISTAN AND 4 Other 1971 SCMR 291
- Syed MAZHAR HUSSAIN RIZVI AND 3 Other vs THE GOVERNMENT OF WEST 1972 PLC 572
- Dr. MUHAMMAD ELIAS DUBASH vs CIVIL SERVICES APPELLATE TRIBUNAL AND 5 1974 PLD Lahore 90
- MESSRS DADA LTD., KARACHI vs SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF PAKISTAN, MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND Another 1974 PLD Karachi 254
- Raja MUHAMMAD SADIQ vs WATER AND POWER DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY 1978 PLD Lahore 738
- Raja MUHAMMAD SADIQ vs WATER AND POWER DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY 1978 PLD Lahore 738
- FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Ministry of Defence and 2 others vs MUHAMMAD KHAN and another 1991 PLD Supreme Court (AJ&K) 33
- Raja MUHAMMAD AKBAR represented by Major Lal Khan and others vs IFTIKHAR JILLANI represented by his Legal Heirs 1991 PLD Supreme Court 71
- Mst. KANEEZ FATIMA vs WALI MUHAMMAD and another 1993 PLD Supreme Court 901
- M/S. SYED BHAIES (Pvt.) LTD. vs GOVERNMENT OF PUNJAB, EXCISE AND 1999 P.C.T.L.R. 1328
- MAQSOOD AHMED TOOR and others vs FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN and another 2000 PLC (C.S.) 1214
- Messrs DAWOOD COTTON MILLS LTD. and others vs GOVERNMENT OF PAKISTAN through Secretary, Ministry of Labour, Pakistan Secretariat, Islamabad and others 2001 PLC 680
- UMAR MUJEEB SHAMI vs DISTRICT MAGISTRATE_DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, ISLAMABAD and 2 others 2003 CLC 430
- SYED BHAIS (PVT) LTD Versus GOVERNMENT OF THE PUNJAB EXCISE AND TAXATION DEPARTMENT 2000 PLD 20
- MUNIR ALAM Versus BOARD OF REVENUE, PUNJAB 1980 PLC(CS) 131