HABIB BANK LIMITED vs Messrs AHMED FOOD INDUSTRIES (PVT.) LTD. and 3
This matter involves a banking suit wherein learned counsel for the parties jointly requested the appointment of a Chartered Accountant or Commissioner to audit the accounts maintained by the defendant with the plaintiff bank from January 1, 1985, to April 30, 2000, to determine the exact liability of the defendant. The core legal question pertained to the ascertainment of financial liabilities regarding Current Finance and Running Finance facilities through a court-commissioned audit. The court accepted the joint request and ordered the appointment of Messrs Mustafa Siddiqui & Co. as the auditor/commissioner, directing them to submit a comprehensive audit report within three months, with the auditor's fee to be settled and borne by defendant No. 1. The principle laid down is that courts may facilitate the settlement of complex financial disputes and accounts through mutual consent of parties by appointing a mutually agreed commissioner for audit.
- Can a court appoint a Chartered Accountant as a Commissioner to audit bank accounts based on the joint request of the parties?
- Whether the fee for a court-appointed auditor to determine financial liability can be ordered to be borne by the defendant?
- What is the procedure for determining liability regarding Current Finance and Running Finance in a banking suit when parties agree to an audit?
ORDER
1. ' Learned counsel for the parties request for appointment of a Chartered Accountant/Commissioner to audit the account maintained by the defendant with the plaintiff w,e,f,, 1-1-1985 to 30-4-2000 for the purpose of audit and with finding as to the liability of the defendant they have agreed for the appointment of Messrs Mustafa Siddiqui & Co., the fee would be settled and borne by defendant No, 1 . The Auditor of Commissioner after auditing the account and liability of the defendant in respect of Current Finance and Running Finance will submit report to the Court within three months.
Cited by 3 cases
- Silk Bank Limited, Karachi vs M/S. Dewan Sugar Mills Limited, Karachi 2011 P.C.T.L.R. 1268
- SILKBANK LIMITED vs Messrs DEWAN SUGAR MILLS LIMITED 2011 CLD 436
- ABDUL KADIR JANGDA and 7 others vs MY BANK LTD. 2007 CLD 349